Статья 'Жизненный путь ученого, полицеиста, видного государственного деятеля, Эдуарда Николаевича Берендтса ' - журнал 'Genesis: исторические исследования' - NotaBene.ru
по
Journal Menu
> Issues > Rubrics > About journal > Authors > About the Journal > Requirements for publication > Editorial collegium > The editors and editorial board > Peer-review process > Policy of publication. Aims & Scope. > Article retraction > Ethics > Online First Pre-Publication > Copyright & Licensing Policy > Digital archiving policy > Open Access Policy > Article Processing Charge > Article Identification Policy > Plagiarism check policy
Journals in science databases
About the Journal

MAIN PAGE > Back to contents
Genesis: Historical research
Reference:

The Life Path of a Scientist, a Police Officer, a Prominent Statesman, Eduard Nikolaevich Berendts

Shamak Slavyana Alekseevna

PhD in Law

assistant professor, St. Petersburg University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia

198206, Russia, g. Saint Petersburg, ul. Pilyutova, 1, kab. 426

nikiforova.slavyana@mail.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 

DOI:

10.25136/2409-868X.2024.1.39660

EDN:

CUVOZN

Received:

24-01-2023


Published:

06-02-2024


Abstract: Determining the prospects for the development of the Russian state, identifying patterns of changes in the legal status of the police, developing new approaches to solving fundamental problems of the theory of state and law in modern conditions cannot be carried out without taking into account the theoretical heritage of outstanding Russian lawyers, among whom belongs Eduard Nikolaevich Berendts (1860-1930), whose name was unreasonably forgotten in the Soviet period. The subject of the study is the biography of Eduard Nikolaevich Berendts. A detailed study of the life, teaching, and service in various departments of E.N. Behrendts helped reconstruct the stages of his state-legal views. In particular, the study of Berendts' life in the Republic of Estonia from 1918 to 1930 helped to find the scientist's works, translate them into Russian, evaluate his views and introduce them into scientific circulation.   The novelty of the study lies in the fact that the biography of E. N. Behrendts has not been fully studied by modern scientists. The little-studied scientific and social activities of the scientist even caused some misunderstandings and inaccuracies, attributing to him publications of which he is not the author. The special contribution of the author of the article lies in the fact that he works with the works of Berendts created in the Republic of Estonia in 1920-1930; with acts resulting from the state and public activities of Berendts in the Russian Empire and his participation in legislative activities in the Republic of Estonia; with the materials of Berendts' private correspondence; with the help of work in the Russian The State Historical Archive, the State Archive of the Russian Federation, the Central State Historical Archive of St. Petersburg, the State Archive of the Yaroslavl Region, the National Archive of the Republic of Estonia, the Department of Archival Documents of the Russian National Library was able to recreate Berendts' biography in detail. This contribution helped to track the dynamics of the development of state-legal ideas and the rich theoretical heritage of E. N. Behrendts.


Keywords:

Eduard Nikolaevich Berendts, policeistics, policeist, Doctor of Financial Law, Senator of the Governing Senate, pre - revolutionary scientist, specialist in Finnish law, administrativist, octobrist, Professor of the University of Tartu

This article is automatically translated. You can find original text of the article here.

 

Currently, modern legal science is increasingly studying personalities who have made an important contribution to the development of state legal doctrines and concepts.

Eduard Nikolaevich Berendts (December 9, 1860, St. Petersburg - August 4, 1930, Tallinn) belongs to the galaxy of these scientists [1, l. 9]., known to the scientific community of the late XIX – early XX centuries. as a specialist in the field of state, police, administrative, financial law, as a scientist, lawyer, statesman and public figure [2, 3].

The subject of Berendts' constant scientific interest were: the mechanism of the state, the organization and structure of the highest bodies of state power; the political and legal relations of the center and its administrative units, especially relations with the suburbs: the Grand Duchy of Finland and the Kingdom of Poland; the relationship between state bodies and individuals and the role of law in regulating these relations; the principles of selection of civil servants and the reasons the emergence of corruption of state bodies; the construction of constitutional and administrative justice in the Russian Empire; the limits of law enforcement activities of the police and police discretion [2, 3, 4].

Many of the provisions of E. N. Behrendts, in particular, in the field of state administration, the creation of a system of administrative courts, and police discretion, remain relevant to the present day.

E. N. Berendts was a multifaceted personality and in order to track the dynamics of the development of his state-legal views, it is necessary to study his biography. Because the new problems and ideas that E. N. Behrendts set for himself were veiled from the sharp turns in his fate.

E. N. Berendts came from a merchant family [7, L. 4].

Father Nikolai Wilhelm Heinrich Behrendts (April 25, 1823 – March 28, 1902), was a native of the German city of Lubeck [7, L. 14; 9, pp. 4-7]. Henry Berendts in his youth, left Germany and moved to Russia. Here he was assigned to the status of hereditary honorary citizens, and the capital at his disposal made it possible to join the merchants of the first guild [7, L. 5; 10, p. 308; 11, pp. 175-176; 12, p. 52].

Mother Maria Julia Charlotte Berendts (March 5, 1835 – June 7, 1899) [7, l. 5]. Her maiden name is Collins. She was the daughter of Eduard Davydovich Collins (July 3, 1791 – August 4, 1840), mathematician of the Russian Empire of the XIX century, ordinary academician of the St. Petersburg Academy of Sciences, director of the St. Peter and Paul school "Petrishule", mathematics teacher Tsarevich Alexander Nikolaevich, the future Emperor Alexander II [13, l. 2-6; 14, l. 367].

E. N. Behrendts of the Lutheran faith [7, l. 2]. At the age of 11, he began attending a German secondary school at the Evangelical Lutheran Church of St. Nicholas. Peter and Paul "Petrishule" in St. Petersburg [15, l. 150; 16, pp. 344-345]. Petrishule is one of the oldest educational institutions in Russia. The first mention of the school dates back to 1709. in a letter from Admiral Cornelius Kruis to Emperor Peter I about the organization of a church and a school attached to it in his estate, then located on the site of the current New Hermitage from Millionnaya Street [17, pp. 16-17].

This educational institution has long been famous for its graduates and high level of teaching, especially in foreign languages. Here E. N. Berendts studied German, Latin, Greek, French, and Hebrew [7, L. 2]. Throughout his studies at Petrishule, he has established himself as an inquisitive, conscientious, responsible and disciplined student [7, L. 2].

In 1880, as E. N. Berendts himself noted in his autobiography, "he entered the administrative category of the Faculty of Law of the Imperial St. Petersburg University" [15, l. 150; 7, l. 1]. Later in his writings, Behrendts gratefully recalled university professors. These were outstanding representatives of Russian legal science: A. D. Gradovsky, I. E. Andreevsky, N. S. Tagantsev, N. L. Duvernois, V. I. Sergeevich, F. F. Martens [10, p. 308; 18, p. 75].

In 1884 Berendts graduated from the Imperial St. Petersburg University and immediately after graduation submitted a petition to the rector of the university for admission to work on his dissertation for a master's degree in financial law, which was approved [7, L. 9].

From 1884 to 1890, E. N. Berendts was engaged in scientific activities, studied materials for his master's thesis in Swedish and translated them. With a law degree, he joined the Department of the State Treasury of the Ministry of Finance [1, l. 9; 15, l. 150]. "By Decree of the Governing Senate dated February 5, 1885, No. 6, he was approved to the rank of collegiate secretary with seniority from the day of his appointment to the service" [19, l. 1 vol.]. An entry in the journal of the Director of the Department of the State Treasury dated February 22, 1885 for No. 13 indicates that Berendts first temporarily served as assistant to the head of the table, and in 1886 was appointed assistant to the head of the table [1, l. 10-10 vol.].

In 1887, E. N. Berendts joined the Department of Agriculture and Rural Industry of the Ministry of State Property [1, l. 10-10 vol.; 15, l. 150].

In January–February 1887 He passed the exams for a master's degree in financial law and submitted a dissertation "The State Economy of Sweden. Part I: The history of the state economy of Sweden before 1809" [20] to the Imperial St. Petersburg University [7, L. 9; 15, L. 150-151].

The formulary list kept in the Estonian National Archive indicates that from 1887 to 1889 E. N. Berendts was a student at the Archaeological Institute in St. Petersburg [21, l 7]. Persons who already had higher education could study at this institute for free (until 1899). The term of study was two years. The St. Petersburg Archaeological Institute trained archivists and archaeologists. Those who completed the course of study at this institute received the title of a full member of the institute or a member of the staff (freelancers) [22].

By Decree of the Governing Senate dated February 11, 1888, No. 548, E. N. Berendts was promoted to titular councillors with seniority for his long service [23, L. 2 vol.] and in the same year he was sent to study in the Archive of the Ministry of State Property [23, l. 2 vol.].

In 1890, E. N. Berendts successfully defended his master's thesis in financial law on the topic: "The state economy of Sweden. Part I: The history of the state economy of Sweden before 1809" [20].

The Council of the Imperial St. Petersburg University approved the Master of Financial Law, in which he was awarded a diploma dated February 15, 1891 No. 226 [19, l. 2 vol.].

E. N. Berendts, linking his life with science, did not want to stop there. In 1891 he submitted a petition addressed to the rector to allow work on a doctoral dissertation [7, l. 14-17].

After receiving a master's degree in financial Law in 1891, E. N. Berendts applied to the director of the Department of Public Education with a request to appoint him an extraordinary professor at the Imperial University of Dorpat at the Department of Financial Law [15, l. 190-194 vol.]. Due to the fact that there was only an associate professor position at the University of Dorpat, E. N. Berendts received motivated refusal.

To this day, it remains a mystery in connection with what caused the desire to teach at the Imperial University of Dorpat. However, according to data obtained from the Estonian National Archive, it is known that E. N. Berendts' brother Alexander Henrikhovich Berendts (September 2, 1863 – February 26, 1912) lived in Dorpat (Tartu). In 1890 Alexander Berendts defended his master's thesis at the Imperial University of Dorpat, and in 1895 was appointed a privatdozent at the Department of Historical Theology at this university [24, l. 34-35].

Fate connected E. N. Berendts with another educational institution – the Demidov Law Lyceum in Yaroslavl. Berendts was appointed by the Minister of Public Education to the position of extraordinary professor of the Demidov Law Lyceum at the Department of State and Administrative Law [23, l. 2 vol.].

Yaroslavl Demidov Law Lyceum was founded in 1803 by P. G. Demidov and was a small higher educational institution [25, l. 2-4]. However, by the end of the XIX century. In terms of the number of law students, he ranked first after the capital's universities [26, pp. 77-78]. Graduates of the Demidov Law Lyceum, as well as students who graduated from the university, received, depending on their achievements, either the title of a valid student or the degree of candidate of Law [27, p. 22].

At the end of the 19th century, the lyceum acquired the status of one of the largest law schools in Russia. On August 30, 1895, E. N. Berendts delivered a speech at the solemn act dedicated to the 25th anniversary of the Legal Lyceum. The scientist noted with deep satisfaction the importance of the contribution made by the Yaroslavl law school to the high formation of Russian legal science, "which not only was able to stand on a par with the European science of law by the end of the XIX century, but managed to rise above it in some respects" [28, L. 2; 29; 26, pp. 77-78].

From 1891-1900 in Yaroslavl, Berendts was engaged in both teaching and social activities. He edited the "Temporary Edition of the Demidov Law Lyceum", took an active part in local history and the archival movement of the Yaroslavl province, in 1895-1900. He was the chairman of the Yaroslavl Scientific Archival Commission and edited its works [30; 31, pp. 207-210; 32, pp. 174-175; 33, pp. 7-8].

By a decree of the Governing Senate for the Department of Heraldry dated November 19, 1892, E. N. Berendts was promoted to collegiate assessors with seniority for years of service [23, l. 2-2 vol.]. This civil rank of the VIII class was very highly appreciated, and it was not easy to achieve it even for a nobleman: a university or lyceum diploma or passing the appropriate the exam.

From August 1 to September 1, 1893, E. N. Berendts was sent to the Grand Duchy of Finland to collect material on his dissertation.

In 1895, at the Imperial St. Petersburg University, E. N. Berendts defended his doctoral dissertation on the topic: "The State economy of Sweden. Part II. Review of the political, social and economic development of Sweden in the XIX century" [15, l. 150; 1, l. 11-11 vol.; 19, l. 3; 7, l. 12-14; 34; 35].

On May 2, 1895, he was appointed Minister of Public Education as an ordinary professor at the Demidov Law Lyceum for State and Administrative Law [23, l. 3 vol.]. And in 1896 By the Highest order for the civil department dated March 12, 1896, No. 17 was approved with the rank of state councilor [23, l. 3 vol.].

In 1900, a major turn in the career of E. N. Behrendts took place. As a leading expert in the field of Finnish law, he was appointed Assistant State Secretary - Minister for the Grand Duchy of Finland and moved from Yaroslavl to St. Petersburg [1, l. 15; 36, l. 3; 25, l. 4 vol.]. "The departure of E. N. Berendts was noted in the chronicle of the Demidov Law Lyceum as a major loss. Being a highly educated, especially diligent teacher, he was distinguished by many qualities that made him highly appreciated among the Lyceum academic corporation and in the local society. Everyone loved him not only as a person, but also as a public figure, who was ready to serve the public interests with his knowledge and work, which was proved by his special useful activity for the Yaroslavl scientific archival commission, of which he was chairman, his very conscientious performance of duties of the Catherine's House of Charity, etc." [31, pp. 209-210].

The duties of the assistants to the State Secretaries of the State Council, and the State secretaries who headed the offices of the State Chancellery under the Council, were: preparation of cases for a report in the departments of the Council; report of cases, by order of the State Secretaries; preparation of draft resolutions; preparation of reports on cases, etc. The Minister of State Secretary of the Grand Duchy of Finland reported to the Emperor the cases arising on the administration of Finland, he presented to him the reports of the Finnish Governor-General and the Finnish Senate, kept in touch with the ministers of the Empire on issues beyond the scope of local Finnish affairs, transmitted the emperor's orders to the bodies of Finnish government and legislation. In August 1899, V. K. was appointed to this position. Plehve. In the person of E. N. Berendts, he found an assistant competent in matters of Finnish law [10, p. 308].

In St. Petersburg, E. N. Berendts did not stop combining public service with teaching. After a two-year break, he resumed teaching.

There were few pre-revolutionary lawyers who were well versed in all the subtleties of Finnish law, which created a number of difficulties both in the local administration of the Grand Duchy of Finland and in office work. "The Ministry of Public Education recognized the urgent need to open special courses on Finnish law" [37; 7, l. 1-8]. In view of this, on May 23, 1901 The Department of Finnish Law was established at the Imperial St. Petersburg University at the Faculty of Law [37]. E. N. Berendts became a supernumerary ordinary professor in this department. From 1901 to 1903 He gave lectures on Finnish law to students of the Faculty of Law, and in the academic year 1901-1902 he served as professor of police law [1, p. 17]. In addition, in 1901 he was appointed acting Chancellor of the Imperial Alexander University in the Grand Duchy of Finland [1, p. 17].

In 1904 By the Highest order for the civil department dated July 5, 1904, No. 50, E. N. Berendts was appointed director of the Demidov Legal Lyceum [1, p. 17; 38]. With the highest diploma dated March 28, 1904, for excellent and diligent service, he was promoted to full state councilors [1, l. 17]. And on October 19, 1904, E. N. Berendts "was appointed by the Emperor as a member of the Preparatory Commission formed by the highest command under the chairmanship of the First Person Present in the Criminal Cassation Department of the Governing Senate, a Valid Privy Councilor to discuss the preferences of national and local Finnish legislation developed in the Commission established by the Imperial Finnish Senate" [1, l. 18-19].

In connection with the release on August 27, 1905 new ministerial rules providing for the electability of the position of director, E. N. Behrendts on September 3, 1905. He was elected by the Council of the Demidov Law Lyceum as the head of the educational institution and went down in its history as the first elected director of the Demidov Law Lyceum [36, l. 3; 34, 10, p. 326; 26, p. 105].

His directorship fell on a troubled time: the rise of the revolutionary movement in the country began, radical and mass political actions of lyceum students took place [26, p. 105]. E. N. Behrendts submitted his resignation, and on December 2, 1905 He was dismissed from the position of director [36, L. 3]. After retirement, he published the newspaper Severyanin in Yaroslavl [31, p. 207, p. 209, p. 222, p. 231, p. 245; 32; 33].

In 1906, he returned to St. Petersburg and resumed teaching. In 1906-1907 he lectured at the Nikolaevsky Cavalry School of Officers and Junkers [40], in 1907 he was a professor at the Imperial School of Jurisprudence in St. Petersburg, where until 1917 he lectured on financial law, the history of Russian law, and the administrative law of Finland [41; 42].

The School of Jurisprudence, established by Nicholas I on the initiative and with the financial support of his nephew Prince P. G. Oldenburg University, was a higher educational institution for the "education of noble youth for judicial service" and was under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Justice. It was a closed educational institution, where only children of nobles could study. The tuition fees were several times higher than the fees for listening to lectures at universities. The boys studied at the College for 7 years, of which the first 4 classes corresponded to the senior classes of secondary school, and the last 3 classes to the course of the Faculty of Law. A special feature of the Law School was its brilliant faculty. Many teachers were at the same time major statesmen. The famous F. F. taught state and international law here. Martens, lectures on the encyclopedia of jurisprudence were given by the former head of the Main Department for Press Affairs of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and a member of the State Council N. A. Zverev, on civil law – Senator S. V. Pakhman, on criminal law – Senator N. D. Sergeevsky and prosecutor of the St. Petersburg District Court S. N. Tregubov, on civil procedure – Director of the First Department of the Ministry justice I. D. Mordukhai-Boltovskaya, in forensic medicine – Senator and chief Prosecutor of the Holy Synod S. M. Lukyanov, in criminal proceedings (from 1903 to March 1917) – I. G. Shcheglovitov, who was Minister of Justice in 1906-1915, and from January 1, 1917 – Chairman of the State Council [10, p. 331].

In March 1908, E. N. Berendts was appointed a member of the Council of the Main Directorate for Press Affairs [41], from 1909 he held a part–time position as a member of the Academic Committee of the Ministry of Public Education, in June 1914 he became a senator of the First Department of the Governing Senate [36, L. 13] to review decisions of provincial presences, where He worked until October 1917 [43, 44, 45, pp. 520-536].

October 1917 brought serious changes to the life of Russia and every Russian. The governing Senate was abolished, and the Imperial Law School was closed. E. N. Berendts was left without a job [4, 6].

In August 1918 he left Russia and emigrated to Estonia [10, p. 336]. There, E. N. Berendts received citizenship. From August 1, 1919, he held the position of consultant to the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Estonia in the field of statistics [21, l. 4], and on October 1, 1919, he was invited to the University of Tartu as a professor of the Department of Financial Law to lecture on political economy [21, l. 4; 46, l. 1; 47, lk. 100-106].

Fate has prepared serious trials for E. N. Behrendts, tearing him away forever from his native and beloved Russia. The scientist was one of those who was never afraid of the twists of fate and did not stop working on himself, believing that the path of a true scientist and lawyer is not easy. In the Republic of Estonia, he managed to adapt to a new life, did not lose his former optimism and ardent passion for science.

In the materials of the Archive of the University of Tartu, lecture plans have been preserved, which since 1919 E. N. Berendts lectured at several departments of the university at once [48; 49]. The subject of the science of financial law was quite broad and the lectures of the scientist were based on the achievements of various sciences: political economy, statistics, legislation of the Republic of Estonia [50].

In 1919-1924 . E. N. Berendts worked part-time as a history teacher at the German gymnasium in Tartu.

The year 1924 became significant for the University of Tartu: reorganization was carried out, new departments and faculties appeared, and the university became multidisciplinary. E. N. Berendts was appointed professor of the entire Faculty of Law [47].

E. N. Behrendts's lectures were so lively, interesting and memorable that students from different faculties came to them, filling all the seats in the audience and listening to lectures standing up. In addition to the established course of lectures, E. N. Berendts, until 1926, additionally, as part of an optional course, lectured on the financial law of tsarist Russia, Finnish law, police law, the history of Russian state law and the legislation of the Republic of Estonia [51].

In Estonia, the scientist gave open lectures, shared his memories of studying at the Imperial St. Petersburg University, serving in the First Department of the Governing Senate, about the reign of Nicholas II, and also wrote polemical portrait essays about Peter I, Grand Duke K. V. Romanov and V. I. Lenin [52, l. 47-51; 53].

The Estonian authorities highly appreciated the scientist, reasonably believing that his ideas and scientific developments could be used to improve the state and legal system of their country [50].

In the mid-1920s, E. N. Berendts was repeatedly invited to Tallinn, where he took part in the legislative design of the public finance system of the Republic of Estonia, in the development of the law on the State Bank of Estonia and the Charter of the Central Bank of the Republic of Estonia [54, p. 86; 55; 56; 57; 50].

E. N. Berendts took an active part in publishing, was the author of articles for the magazines "Erigus" (in 1920-1923), "Eesti Majandus" (in 1921-1925), "Majaomanik" (in 1924), "Eesti politseileht" (in 1923-1925), as well as the newspapers "Tallinna Teatja", "Revaler Bote", "Dorpater Zeitung", "Life" (1920), "Latest News" (in 1921-1930), "Old Narva Leaflet", "Today". [2, 6].

In the Republic of Estonia, E. N. Berendts was a member of the Russian Academic Group. This organization sought to solve various tasks, including: uniting Russian scientists in Estonia, assisting them in professional pursuits, conducting scientific events, establishing links with scientific circles and academic societies in other countries, caring for young personnel, and material support for group members [54, p. 84; 58, p. 4-8].

E. N. Berendts was a member of the society "Reasonable Leisure" and was a member of the editorial board of collections dedicated to the Day of Russian Enlightenment, which were published from 1926 to 1929. In 1922 he published a manual for Russian schools in Estonia, An Essay on the History of Estonia. He took an active part in the life of the University of Tartu.

After 1926, E. N. Berendts was seriously ill for a long time. Despite his illness, having finally lost his eyesight, he continued to lecture students both in the hospital and at home [48, l. 27-30; 61; 50, p. 105].

The life path of the scientist, lawyer, teacher, writer, politician and statesman of imperial Russia E. N. Berendts ended on August 4, 1930 in Tallinn [59; 60; 42, pp. 91-94; 16, pp. 344-345; 61]. Behrendts died at the age of 69 and was buried in Tallinn at the Lutheran cemetery, located on the outskirts of the Kopli district in Tallinn [21, l. 16]. Today, a public park is located on the territory of the cemetery, which has not preserved any visible traces of the past. The only surviving evidence of those who were buried there are records in the metric books and on some old maps of the area in the Tallinn archive.

E. N. Behrendts was accompanied on his last journey by his closest relatives and friends. The eulogies were delivered by Professor Piip on behalf of the University of Tartu and Professor Greving on behalf of the Russian Academic Group in Estonia, whose devotion Berendts retained until his death [39, p. 69].

An obituary published in the Reval newspaper Postimees dated August 7, 1930, noted the merits of an outstanding scientist and a former high-ranking Russian dignitary. "In the deceased, whose death was greeted with deep sorrow far beyond the borders of Estonia, we lost a man who worked tirelessly in the spiritual field, who had a rare gift for predicting historical events and drawing correct conclusions from the results of his mental activity. We will always remember him with deep gratitude for the tremendous work he did during his lifetime in numerous fields."[61]

E. N. Behrendts' contemporaries noted that he was a strong, multifaceted lawyer of the 1920s. He was helped to achieve high results in science and law not only by the education he received in St. Petersburg and the experience of serving in various departments of the Russian Empire, but also by constant work on himself.

The obituary about E. N. Berendts in the newspaper Vesti of the Day reported: "Professor of the Yuriev University, a prominent Russian scientist E. N. Berendts, who lived here after his retirement, died in Reval. He died at an advanced age. He had been ill for a long time, and for the last three years he had been completely blind, however, continuing to lecture.

Eduard Nikolaevich Berendts was born in 1860. He received his secondary education at St. Peter's Church school in St. Petersburg. From 1880 to 1884, he took a course in law at St. Petersburg University; graduated from the university with the title of Candidate of Law. Then he served in the Ministry of Internal Affairs, Public Education, Finance and State Property.

In 1891, E. N. Berendts passed the exam for the title of Master of Financial Law, and two years later he was awarded the degree of Doctor of Financial Law. From 1891 to 1900 He is an extraordinary professor at the Yaroslavl Demidov Lyceum; subsequently, he holds the post of first assistant, and then director of the lyceum. From 1901 to 1904, he was the State Secretary for the Grand Duchy of Finland, at the same time lecturing at St. Petersburg University as an ordinary professor. From 1907 to 1918 He also lectures at the Imperial College of Jurisprudence. From 1914 to 1917, he was a senator of the First Department of the Governing Senate.

After the revolution, E. N. Berendts left Russia and moved permanently to Estonia, where he was appointed consultant to the Ministry of Internal Affairs on August 1, 1919. From October 1, 1919 He reads financial law at the Faculty of Law of the Yuriev University, and subsequently statistics, philosophy of law and the general doctrine of law. He was a member of the Russian Academic Group in Estonia.

Professor E. N. Berendts is the author of numerous scientific works, including "Financial Law of Finland", The Past and Present of the Russian Administration, "The State Economy of Sweden", etc.

The death of E. N. Behrendts is a huge loss for Russian science" [59].

Awards and honorary titles:

1909 – Order of St. Vladimir, 3rd degree;

1911 – Order of St. Stanislaus, 1st degree;

1914 Order of St. Anna, 2nd degree.

Estate (1905) – ancestral: with brothers and sisters a stone house in St. Petersburg and in Pavlovsk a country house at the address: B. Sadovaya, 16-2, 1200 square fathoms [1, l. 24 vol.; 7, l. 37].

In St. Petersburg from 1907-1918, E. N. Berendts lived at the address: Kadetskaya liniya, 7. sq. 3 [1, l. 24 vol.; 7, l. 37]. Whether it was his property or his office apartment has not been established.

Wife: Sofya Aminovna Findeisen (October 23, 1863 – 1916) [62].

Children: Elizabeth Eduardovna Berendts (December 9, 1885 – 1911); Julia Maria Eduardovna Berendts (April 16, 1887 – June 2, 1929); Sofia Eduardovna Berendts (August 19, 1891 – ?); Eduard Eduardovich Berendts (November 24, 1894 – 1919); Wilhelmina Eduardovna Berendts (July 21, 1901 – ?); Ingeborg Eduardovna Berendts (November 1, 1904 – ?) [1, L. 9; 62].

Sofia Eduardovna Berendts (August 19, 1891 – ?) graduated from the women's gymnasium and Higher Women's Courses in Petrograd [63]. Before the revolution, she worked as a senior archivist. Departments II Sections of the Unified State Archival Fund (former Senate Archive) in St. Petersburg [63]. She lived, according to the Estonian National Archive, until 1920 in Petrograd at the address: 11-Vasilyevsky Island line, 46. sq. 2 [64]. In 1920, she moved to permanent residence in the Republic of Estonia, in the city of Tartu [64].

References
1. Russian State Historical Archive (RSHA). F. 740. Op. 24. D. 845. L. 9.
2. Nizhnik, N. S., & Nikiforova, S. A. (2019). State and law in the theoretical and legal views of E. N. Berendts. Moscow: Yurlitinform.
3. Nikiforova, S. A. (2019). State legal views of E. N. Berendts: Dis. … cand. legal Sciences (pp. 66-67). SPb.
4. Shamak, S.A. (2015). Russian police studies in faces: Eduard Nikolaevich Berendts. Genesis: historical research, 6, 828–843.
5. Shamak, S.A. (2017). Nature, social essence and features of the state-the subject of theoretical and legal research by E. N. Berendts. Genesis: historical research, 11, 96–111.
6. Shamak, S.A. & Senator, E. N. (2022). Berendts on the work of the Governing Senate in the context of the revolutionary changes of 1917. Genesis: historical research, 2, 32–39.
7. Central State Historical Archive (CSHA). F. 14. Op. 3. D. 21059. L. 1-10.
8. Brockhaus, F. A., Efron, I. A. (1912). New Encyclopedic Dictionary: V. 29 v. T. 6 (pp. 94–95). Berard-Bobrovnikova. SPb.
9. Berendts, E. N. (1902). The funeral of Schrenburger Nikolai Wilhelm Heinrich Berendts (4-7). St. Petersburg.
10. Zinovatny, P. S. (2014). "Serve the Truth": E. N. Berendts (1860-1930). Brief essay on life and work. Berendts EN Russian financial law, 308–340. Moscow.
11. Germans of Russia: Encyclopedia. (1999). In 3 vols. T. 1. A–I. Editorial Board: V. Karaev (presiding editorial board) and others (175–176). Moscow: ERN.
12. Encyclopedia "Russian Germans". (1997). Methodological materials. Issue. 2. Moscow.
13. CSHA. F. 272. Op. 1. D. 123. L. 1-10.
14. RSHA. F. 1263. Op. 1. D. 215. L. 367.
15. RSHA. F. 733. Op. 150. D. 625. L. 150.
16. Russian Biographical Dictionary: In 20 vols. T. 2: B-Blagorazov. (1998) (pp. 344–345). Moscow: TERRA–Knizhny Klub.
17. Smirnov, V. V. (2006). St. Petrischule, School, which is on Nevsky Prospekt behind the church: the oldest school in St. Petersburg. 1709–2005, 16–17 St. Petersburg: Kolo.
18. Mantseva, N. G., Yatsuk, E. A., & Anisimov, O. V. (2012). Famous students of St. Petersburg University. Faculty of Law. SPb.: Ed. House of St. Petersburg State University.
19. CSHA. F. 355. Op. 1. D. 5470. L. 1-10.
20. Berendts, E.N. (1890). State economy of Sweden. Part I: History of the state economy of Sweden until 1809. St. Petersburg.
21. Estonian State Archives (ESA). F. 50. N. 12. S. 363. L. 1-30.
22. Archaeological Institute in St. Petersburg: Its first decade, 1878–1888: Ceremonial meeting on January 15, 1888. St. Petersburg.
23. CSHA. F. 355. Op. 1. D. 5470. L. 1-10.
24. Estonian Historical Archive (EHA). F. 384. N. 1. S. 3294. L. 1-40.
25. RSHA. F. 732. Op. 1. D. 117. L. 1-10.
26. Egorov, S. A., Lushnikova, A. M., & Tarusina, N. N. (2009). Yaroslavl Law School: past, present, future (pp. 77–78). Yaroslavl: YarGU.
27. The Highest Approved Provisional Charter of the Demidov Legal Lyceum of July 3, 1868. Complete Collection of Laws of the Russian Empire. Collection 2. Vol. 43. Part 2. No. 46075. P. 22.
28. State archive of the Yaroslavl region (SAYR). F. 571. Op. 1. D. 1. L.1-15.
29. Vremennik of the Demidov Legal Lyceum. Yaroslavl, 1897. Book. 71. P. 3.
30. SAYR. F. 582. Op. 1. D. 16. L. 1-15.
31. Pokrovsky, S. P. (2012). Demidov Lyceum in Yaroslavl in its past and present. Repr. Play 1914 editions [foreword]. D. K. Morozova; biogr. och. E. V. Gushchina]. Yaroslavl, Rybinsk: Rybinsk Printing House Publishing House, . P. 207, P. 209, P. 222, P. 231, P. 245.
32. Encyclopedia of the Yaroslavl region from ancient times to 1917 anthrology. (2009). Yaroslavl state. un-t im. P. G. Demidova, Group of Companies "YarInvestProekt"; ch. ed. Yu. Yu. Ierusalimsky (pp. 174–175). Yaroslavl: YarInvestProekt.
33. Yaroslavl local historians: Bibliographer. index, annotated. (1988). Comp. V. P. Alekseev. Part 1, pp. 7–8. Yaroslavl: Yar. Historical and Architectural Museum-Reserve.
34. Berendts EN State economy of Sweden. (1894). Part II. Issue. I: An overview of the political, social and economic development of Sweden in the 19th century. Yaroslavl.
35. Egorov, S. A. Berendts Eduard Nikolaevich. Legal science and legal ideology of Russia. Encyclopedic Dictionary of Biographies. Ed. ed. V. M. Syrykh, 67–69.
36. RSHA. F. 1405. Op. 544. D. 1060. L. 1-10.
37. RSHA. F. 1153. Op. 1. D. 38. L. 1-12.
38. Guschina, H., Morozov, D., & Salova, J. (2010). Who is who at the Demidov University a historical view, 50-52. Yaroslavl, Rybinsk.
39. Belsky, K. S. (2010). Doctor of Financial Law, administrative scientist and senator of the Russian Empire (To the 150th anniversary of the birth of E. N. Berendts). State and Law, 12, 60-69.
40. Berendts, E. N. (1908). About the state: conversations with the junkers of the Nikolaev Cavalry School in the 1906-1907 academic year. Issue. 1. St. Petersburg: Type. M. M. Stasyulevich.
41. RSHA. F. 776. Op. 23. D. 18. L. 1-10.
42. Volkov, V. A., Kulikova, M. V., & Loginov, V. S. (2013). Russian professorship. XVIII-early XX century. Humanitarian sciences. Biographical Dictionary. Part I: A–I (pp. 91-92). SPb.
43. Murzanov, N. A. (2011). Dictionary of Russian senators. 1711-1917: Materials for biographies. Ed. prepared D. N. Shilov. St. Petersburg: "Dmitry Bulanin".
44. Syrykh, V. M. (2009). Berendts Eduard Nikolaevich. Legal science and legal ideology of Russia: an encyclopedic dictionary of biographies. In 4 vols. T. 1: XI-the beginning of the XX century (pp. 67–69). Moscow: RAP.
45. Tomsinov, V. A. (2007). Russian jurists of the XVIII XX centuries. Essays on life and work: In 2 vols. T. 2. (pp. 520–536). Moscow.
46. ESA. F. 1108. N. 19. S. 34. L. 1-40.
47. Haljaste, E. (1989). Overview of the development of the Faculty of Economics of the University of Tartu 1920–1940 (pp. 100-106). University of Tartu historical questions VIII. Tartu.
48. EHA. F. 2100. N. 2 yrs. S. 4. L. 1-30.
49. Economics at the University of Tartu 1920–1940. (1989). University of Tartu history issues XXIII (pp. 170-174). Tartu.
50. Leesment, L. (1977). Kôige about the more versatile Tartu law professor. University of Tartu history questions IV (pp. 97-103). Tartu.
51. Russian public and cultural figures of Estonia: materials for a biographical dictionary. (1996). T. 1. (until 1940): dictionary. Compiled by S. G. Isakov. 2nd ed., rev. and additional Tallinn.
52. EHA. F. 2111. N. 2. S. 167. L. 1-60.
53. Chronicle of Russian cultural and social life in Estonia (1918–1940). (1923). Materials for the history of the Russian Diaspora. P. 12, 26, 31, 37. Tallinn.
54. Isakov, S. G. (2011). The culture of Russian emigration in Estonia 1918–1940: articles, essays, archival publications. Tallinn.
55. Shor, T. (2001). Russian teachers at the University of Tartu. Russian national minority in the Republic of Estonia (1918–1940) (pp. 212–213). Tartu–St. Petersburg.
56Baltischer Biographischer Index, 1, 67.
57. Biographical lexicon of Estonian science. (2006). T. Volume 1 A–Kj. Chief editor Karl Siilivask. Estonian Encyclopedia publishing house (pp. 132-133). Tallinn.
58. Russian academic group in Estonia. (1931). Essay on activity of the academic group for ten years (December 9, 1920–1930). Yuriev.
59. Berendts, E. Н. (1930). News of the Day. N. 210 (1362). August 8. P. 1.
60. Berendts, Eduard. (1912). New Encyclopedic Dictionary. Publishers F. A. Brockhaus, I. A. Efron. V. 29 vol. T. 6 (pp. 94-95). St. Petersburg.
61. Berendts, Eduard. (1930). Postman. № 211. August. P. 1.
62. Amburger, E. (1994). Die Nachkommen Leonhard Eulers in den ersten sechs Generationen. E. Amburger, I Hecker, G. Michajlow. Basler Zeitschrift für Geschichte und Altertumskunde, 94, 20.
63. ESA. F. 28. N. 2. S. 1097. L. 1-30.
64. ESA. F. 1. N. 3. S. 5555. L. 1-25.

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

A REVIEW of an article on the topic "The life path of a scientist, a policeman, a prominent statesman, Eduard Nikolaevich Berendts." The subject of the study. The article proposed for review is devoted to the description and research of the life path of "... a scientist, a policeman, a prominent statesman, Eduard Nikolaevich Berendts." The author has chosen a special subject of research: the proposed issues are studied from the point of view of history, political science, theory of state and law, history of state and law of Russia and Finland, while the author notes that "At present, in modern legal science, personalities who have made an important contribution to the development of state-legal doctrines and concepts are increasingly being studied. Eduard Nikolaevich Berendts belongs to the galaxy of these scientists...". Historical documents relevant to the purpose of the study are being studied. A large volume of scientific literature on the stated issues is also studied and summarized, analysis and discussion with these opposing authors are present. At the same time, the author notes: "Many of the provisions of E. N. Behrendts, in particular, in the field of state administration, the creation of a system of administrative courts, and police discretion, remain relevant to the present time." Research methodology. The purpose of the study is determined by the title and content of the work: "E. N. Berendts was a multifaceted personality and in order to track the dynamics of the development of his state-legal views, it is necessary to study his biography. Because the new problems and ideas that E. N. Behrendts set for himself were veiled from the sharp turns in his fate." They can be designated as the consideration and resolution of certain problematic aspects related to the above-mentioned issues and the use of certain experience. Based on the set goals and objectives, the author has chosen a certain methodological basis for the study. The author uses a set of general scientific, private scientific methods of cognition. In particular, the methods of analysis and synthesis made it possible to generalize approaches to the proposed topic and influenced the author's conclusions. Historical methods played the greatest role. In particular, the author used methods that made it possible to analyze and interpret historical documents, analyze and compare them. In particular, the following conclusions are drawn: "Professor E. N. Berendts is the author of numerous scientific works, including he wrote "Financial Law of Finland", The past and present of the Russian administration", "State Economy of Sweden", etc.", etc. Thus, the methodology chosen by the author is fully adequate to the purpose of the article, allows you to study many aspects of the topic. The relevance of the stated issues is beyond doubt. This topic is important in Russia, from a legal point of view, the work proposed by the author can be considered relevant, namely, he notes "In 1884, Berendts graduated from the Imperial St. Petersburg University and immediately after graduation submitted a petition to the rector of the university for admission to work on a dissertation for a master's degree in financial law ...". And in fact, an analysis of the opponents' work should follow here, and it follows and the author shows the ability to master the material. Thus, scientific research in the proposed field is only to be welcomed. Scientific novelty. The scientific novelty of the proposed article is beyond doubt. It is expressed in the specific scientific conclusions of the author. Among them, for example, is this: "From 1891-1900 in Yaroslavl, Berendts was engaged in both teaching and social activities. He edited the "Temporary Edition of the Demidov Law Lyceum", took an active part in local history and the archival movement of the Yaroslavl province ...". As can be seen, these and other "theoretical" conclusions can be used in further research. Thus, the materials of the article as presented may be of interest to the scientific community. Style, structure, content. The subject of the article corresponds to the specialization of the journal "Genesis: Historical Research", as it is devoted to the description and study of the life path of "... a scientist, a policeman, a prominent statesman, Eduard Nikolaevich Berendts". The article contains an analysis of the opponents' scientific works, so the author notes that a question close to this topic has already been raised and the author uses their materials, discusses with opponents. The content of the article corresponds to the title, since the author considered the stated problems and achieved the goal of his research. The quality of the presentation of the study and its results should be recognized as improved. The subject, objectives, methodology, research results, and scientific novelty directly follow from the text of the article. The design of the work meets the requirements for this kind of work. No significant violations of these requirements were found, except for grammatical descriptions in the article "political and legal relations of the center and its administrative units" (center), "with the title of candidate of rights" (law), etc. The bibliography is quite complete, contains historical acts and documents, scientific research, to which the author refers. This allows the author to correctly identify problems and put them up for discussion. The quality of the literature presented and used should be highly appreciated. The works of these authors correspond to the research topic, have a sign of sufficiency, and contribute to the disclosure of many aspects of the topic. Appeal to opponents. The author has analyzed the current state of the problem under study. The author describes the opponents' different points of view on the problem, argues for a more correct position in his opinion, based on the work of individual opponents, and offers solutions to individual problems. Conclusions, the interest of the readership. The conclusions are logical, concrete "... E. N. Berendts was elected by the Council of the Demidov Law Lyceum as the head of the educational institution on September 3, 1905 and entered its history as the first elected director of the Demidov Law Lyceum", etc. The article in this form may be of interest to the readership in terms of the systematic positions of the author in relation to the issues stated in the article. Based on the above, summing up all the positive and negative sides of the article, I recommend "publishing".
Link to this article

You can simply select and copy link from below text field.


Other our sites:
Official Website of NOTA BENE / Aurora Group s.r.o.