Kostrigin A.A., Stoyukhina N.Y.
Speculative and Introspective Psychology in Russia in the XIXth - early XXth Centuries: Definition of Concepts and Their Borders
// Psychology and Psychotechnics.
2016. № 9.
P. 755-765.
DOI: 10.7256/2454-0722.2016.9.21458 URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=21458
Умозрительная и интроспективная психология в России в XIX – начале XX вв.: определение понятий, границы направлений
Kostrigin Artem Andreevich
PhD in Psychology
senior lecturer of the Department of Psychology at Kosygin Russian State University
117997, Russia, g. Moscow, ul. Sadovnicheskaya, 33
Abstract: The article considers the problem of formation of the Russian psychology in the XIXth - early XXth centuries. The authors analyze approaches of Russian researchers in the history of psychology to studying the structure of psychology in Russia during the aforesaid period. The authors note that there is no common terminological field and understanding of the content of areas in the psychological science. The traditional classification which distinguishes an experimental, empirical and religious-philosophical psychology is insensitive to those scientists and their concepts who worked in several directions or held certain views in the declared positions, but in their works used other ideas. The authors propose their own classification of directions of psychology in Russia in the XIXth - early XXth century based on the dominant method for obtaining psychological knowledge (speculation, introspection, experiment and measurement): speculative psychology, introspective psychology and experimental psychology. The authors examine only speculative and introspective psychology because there is the greatest uncertainty and ambiguity related to these directions, their representatives, concepts, and methods (speculation and introspection). The methods of historical and psychological research include structural-analytical method and method of analysis of the framework of categories and concepts. This theoretical study is methodological, approaches of representatives of speculative and introspective psychology are analyzed by the authors in terms of the subject and method of psychology. The authors have developed their own classification of directions of Russian psychology in the XIXthe – early XXth century offering a new basis, the method of obtaining psychological knowledge (speculation, introspection, experiment). In each direction the authors have defined two vectors corresponding to a particular conception of the nature of the subject of psychology: substantial psychology (soul as an independent substance) and functional psychology (psyche as a function of the brain and nervous system). The final classification is as follows: 1) speculative substantial psychology and speculative functional psychology; 2) introspective substantial psychology and introspective functional psychology; 3) experimental substantial psychology and experimental functional psychology.
Keywords:
history of psychology, Russian psychology, method of psychology, subject of psychology, classification, speculative psychology, introspective psychology, experimental psychology, soul, psyche
References
1. Avsenev P.S. Iz zapisok po psikhologii. SPb.: Tropa Troyanova, 2008. 335 s.
2. Anan'ev B.G. Ocherki istorii russkoi psikhologii XVIII i XIX vekov. M.: Gospolitizdat, 1947. 168 s.
3. Anshakova V.V. Problema lichnosti v eksperimental'nom, empiricheskom i dukhovno-nravstvennom napravleniyakh otechestvennoi psikhologicheskoi mysli v kontse XIX - nachale XX stoletii: diss. ... dokt. psikhologich. nauk: 19.00.01. Astrakhan', 2005. 365 s.
4. Anshakova V.V. Problema lichnosti i ee proyavlenii v otechestvennoi psikhologicheskoi mysli kontsa XIX – nachala XX stoletii // Metodologiya i istoriya psikhologii. 2007. T. 2. № 2. S. 79-93.
5. Artem'eva O.A. Otechestvennaya psikhologiya na perelome: urovnevaya sub''ektnaya kontseptsiya sotsial'no-psikhologicheskoi determinatsii razvitiya psikhologii. Irkutsk: Izd-vo IGU, 2012. 382 s.
6. Artem'eva O.A. Sotsial'naya biografiya russkoi dukhovnoi psikhologii (istoriko-psikhologicheskii analiz) // Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Svyato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Seriya 4: Pedagogika. Psikhologiya. 2011. № 18.(20). S. 153-169.
7. Batyrshina A.R. Istoriya psikhologii. M.: FLINTA : Nauka, 2011. 224 s.
8. Bogdanchikov S.A. Otechestvennaya idealisticheskaya psikhologiya 1920-kh godov // Voprosy psikhologii. 2007. № 2. S. 152-160.
9. Bol'shakova V.V. Ocherki istorii russkoi psikhologii. Chast' 2. Russkii volyuntarizm: M.I. Vladislavlev. Nizhnii Novgorod: Izd-vo Volgo-Vyatskoi akademii gosudarstvennoi sluzhby, 1997. 146 s.
10. Budilova E.A. Bor'ba materializma i idealizma v russkoi psikhologicheskoi nauke (vtoraya polovina XIX – nachalo XX v.). M.: Izdatel'stvo Akademii nauk SSSR, 1960. 348 s.
11. Budilova E.A. Filosofskie problemy v sovetskoi psikhologii. M.: Nauka, 1972. 336 s.
12. Gusel'tseva M.S. Problema periodizatsii istorii otechestvennogo psikhologicheskogo znaniya // Psikhologicheskie issledovaniya. 2013. T. 6. № 29. S. 11.
13. Zhdan A.N. Istoriya psikhologii. Ot Antichnosti do nashikh dnei. M.: Akademicheskii proekt, 2004. 576 s.
14. Zhuravlev A.L., Ushakov D.V. Fundamental'naya psikhologiya i praktika: problemy i tendentsii vzaimodeistviya // Psikhologicheskii zhurnal. 2011. T. 32. № 3. S. 5-16.
15. Zen'ko Yu.M. Psikhologiya i religiya. SPb.: Aleteiya, 2002. 384 s.
16. Zen'ko Yu.M. Osnovy khristianskoi antropologii i psikhologii. SPb.: Rech', 2007. 912 s.
17. Karpovich M.M. Lektsii po intellektual'noi istorii Rossii (XVIII – nachalo XX veka). M.: Russkii put', 2012. 352 s.
18. Kol'tsova V.A. Psikhologiya v Rossii nachala XX veka (predrevolyutsionnyi period) // Psikhologicheskaya nauka v Rossii XX stoletiya: problemy teorii i istorii / Pod red. A.V. Brushlinskogo. M.: Izdatel'stvo «Institut psikhologii RAN», 1997. 576 s. S. 10-48.
19. Kostrigin A.A. «Istoriya dushi» P.S. Avseneva kak psikhologicheskaya distsiplina // PEM: Psychology. Educology. Medicine. 2015. № 3-4. S. 20-29.
20. Kostrigin A.A. Snegirev Veniamin Alekseevich: dannye bibliografii rabot № 1 // Istoriya rossiiskoi psikhologii v litsakh: Daidzhest. 2015. № 1. S. 32-37.
21. Levchenko E.V. Istoriya i teoriya psikhologii otnoshenii / Otv. red. A.A. Krylov. SPb.: Aleteiya, 2003. 312 s.
22. Mazilov V.A. Aktual'nye metodologicheskie problemy sovremennoi otechestvennoi istorii psikhologii // Yaroslavskii pedagogicheskii vestnik. 2014. № 2. S. 202-210.
23. Mazilov V.A. Metodologiya psikhologicheskoi nauki: istoriya i sovremennost'. Yaroslavl', 2007. S. 33.
24. Mazilov V.A. Metodologicheskie problemy issledovaniya v istorii psikhologii // Yaroslavskii pedagogicheskii vestnik. 2015. № 1. S. 91-97.
25. Mazilov V.A. Psikhologiya akademicheskaya i prakticheskaya: aktual'noe sosushchestvovanie i perspektivy // Psikhologicheskii zhurnal. 2015. T. 36. № 3. S. 80-90. S. 89.
26. Mazilov V.A. Teoriya i metod v psikhologii. Yaroslavl': MAPN, 1998. 356 s.
27. Martsinkovskaya T.D. Istoriya psikhologii. M.: Izdatel'skii tsentr «Akademiya», 2004. 544 s.
28. Mekhtikhanova N.N. Istoriya otechestvennoi psikhologii kontsa XIX – nachala XX v. M.: FLINTA: NOU VPO «MPSI», 2010. 192 s.
29. Ponomarev Ya.A. Metodologicheskoe vvedenie v psikhologiyu. M.: Nauka, 1980.
30. Sirotkina I.E., Smit R. Istoriya psikhologii v Rossii: kratkii obzor s avtorskimi aktsentami // Vestnik Novosibirskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Psikhologiya. 2015. T. 9. № 1. S. 5-39.
31. Stoyukhina N.Yu. Religiozno-filosofskii psikholog M.S. Grigorevskii i pedagogicheskaya psikhologiya // Nauchno-metodicheskii elektronnyi zhurnal Kontsept. 2016. T. 15. S. 2501-2505.
32. Stoyukhina N.Yu. Religiozno-filosofskaya psikhologiya v tvorchestve N.M. Bogolyubova // Psikhologicheskaya nauka i obrazovanie www.psyedu.2014. 2014. № 1. S. 198-208.
33. Stoyukhina N.Yu., Mazilov V.A. Chetverikov Ivan Pimenovich: dannye biografii № 1 // Istoriya rossiiskoi psikhologii v litsakh: daidzhest. 2016. № 4. S. 34-50.
34. Yaroshevskii M.G. Istoriya psikhologii. Ot antichnosti do serediny XX v. M., 1996. 416 s.
35. Joravsky D. Russian psychology: a critical history. Oxford: Blackwell, 1989. 583 p.
36. Sirotkina I., Smith R. Russian Federation // The Oxford Handbook of the History of Psychology: Global Perspectives / D. Baker (ed.). N.Y.: Oxford University Press, 2012. P. 412–442.
37. Kovalevskii V.G. K voprosu o klyuchevykh ponyatiyakh v filosofsko-psikhologicheskom uchenii S.L. Franka // Filosofiya i kul'tura. 2012. № 11. C. 72-76.
38. Maksimov L.V. Chto takoe moral': problema opredeleniya // Filosofiya i kul'tura. 2012. № 10. C. 115-126.
39. Gurevich P.S. Freid beskonechnyi i mertsayushchii // Filosofiya i kul'tura. 2016. № 5. C. 625-628. DOI: 10.7256/1999-2793.2016.5.19149.
Link to this article
You can simply select and copy link from below text field.