Kholodilin K.A., Gerasymov T.Y.
The Origin of the Housing Crisis and the Fight with its Consequences: Right-Bank Ukraine in 1914-1921
// History magazine - researches.
2017. ¹ 1.
P. 115-128.
DOI: 10.7256/2454-0609.2017.1.20711 URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=20711
Âîçíèêíîâåíèå æèëèùíîãî êðèçèñà è áîðüáà ñ åãî ïîñëåäñòâèÿìè: Ïðàâîáåðåæíàÿ Óêðàèíà â 1914–1918 ãã.
Kholodilin Konstantin Arkad'evich
Senior Research Associate, Deutsches Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung
Mohrenstraße street 58, Berlin 10117 Germany
renoloco@yandex.ru
Gerasymov Tymofiy Yur‘yevich
PhD in History
GERASIMOV Timofei Yuryevich - Assistant, Department of History and Culture of Ukraine, Mykhailo Kotsiubynsky Vinnytsia State Pedagogical University;
Abstract: The object of the current research is the resulting from the First World War housing crisis and the reaction to it by the government. In this article the government's interference in the market of rental housing is examined on the example of Right-Bank Ukraine in 1914-1921. Within the framework of this study the authors identify the factors that prompted the authorities to regulate the relationship between the property owners and the house tenants, trace the changes in the housing laws on the regional and national levels and analyse the effectiveness of the government’s intervention. In this research the authors used the methods of: 1) the analysis of publications in the Ukrainian press from the time of the First World War in order to reveal the acuteness of the housing problem, the property owners' abuse and the attitude towards this issue by society; 2) the analysis and comparison of the legislative acts regulating in 1915-1918 the relations between the homeowners and the tenants. With the help of the second method the authors could identify the changes in the regulation intensity. The topic's novelty lies in it absolutely not being previously studied: despite the fact that Russia was one of the first countries that resorted to this kind of regulation, its origins and mechanism remain a white spot. In particular, the formation on this policy in different regions of the former Russian Empire remain completely unexamined.
Keywords:
daily life, housing crisis, housing issue, refugees, tenant protection, Right-Bank Ukraine, First World War, government regulations, rent control, rental housing market
References
1. ²stor³ya m³st ³ s³l Ukra¿ns'ko¿ RSR. Ki¿v : Gol. red. URE AN URSR, 1966–1973 g.
2. Kondufor Yu.Yu. T. 2. Kiev perioda pozdnego feodalizma i kapitalizma. Istoriya Kieva: 3-kh t., 4-kh kn. / AN USSR, In-t istorii. Kiev: Naukova dumka, 1983 g. 463 s.
3. V³nnitsya: ³storichnii naris. V³nnitsya: Kn.-gaz.vid-vo, 1964 g. 354 s.
4. V³l'shans'ka O. Povsyakdenne zhittya naselennya Ukra¿ni p³d chas Persho¿ sv³tovo¿ v³ini. Ukra¿ns'kii ³storichnii zhurnal. ¹ 4. 2004 g. S. 56–70.
5. Molchanov V.B. Vpliv Persho¿ sv³tovo¿ v³ini na zhittºvii r³ven' naselennya Ukra¿ni. Problemi ³stor³¿ Ukra¿ni Kh²Kh – pochatku KhKh st. Vip. KhX²²². Kiev: ²nstitut ³stor³¿ Ukra¿ni, 2014 g. S. 92–102.
6. V³tyuk, O. O. Zakhodi m³s'kikh dum shchodo regulyuvannya zhitlovikh v³dnosin sered naselennya na Pod³ll³ u 1917-1919 rr. Naukov³ prats³ ³storichnogo fakul'tetu Zapor³z'kogo nats³onal'nogo un³versitetu. 2013. Vip. 37. S. 97-100.
7. Gerasimov T.Yu. Vpliv kvartirnogo zakonodavstva 1917–1918 rr. na zhitlov³ umovi meshkants³v pod³l's'kikh m³st dobi Get'manatu P. Skoropads'kogo (kv³ten'-gruden' 1918 r.). Naukov³ prats³ Kam'yanets'-Pod³l's'kogo nats³onal'nogo un³versitetu ³men³ ²vana Og³ºnka: ²storichn³ nauki. T. 21. S. 422–429. Kam'yanets'-Pod³l's'kii: Aks³oma, 2011 g.
8. Prishchepa O.P. M³sta Pravoberezhno¿ Ukra¿ni k³ntsya KhV²²² – pochatku KhKh st.: suchasnii stan dosl³dzhen' ta perspektivi vivchennya. Naukovii v³snik Skh³dnoºvropeis'kogo nats³onal'nogo un³versitetu ³men³ Les³ Ukra¿nki. ²storichn³ nauki. 12 2013 g. S. 131-139.
9. Gumenyuk A.O. Rol' m³grats³inikh protses³v u formuvann³ m³s'kogo naselennya Pravoberezhno¿ Ukra¿ni (1861–1914 rr.). Naukov³ prats³ Kam’yanets'-Pod³l's'kogo derzhavnogo un³versitetu: ²storichn³ nauki. Kam’yanets'-Pod³l's'kii: O³yum, 2004. S. 114-120.
10. Rashin A.G. Naselenie Rossii za 100 let (1811-1913): statisticheskie ocherki. M.: Gosudarstvennoe statisticheskoe izdatel'stvo, 1956. 352 s.
11. Statisticheskii ezhegodnik Rossii. 1914 g. (God odinnadtsatyi). Petrograd: Izdanie Tsentral'nogo statisticheskogo komiteta MVD, 1915 g. 352 c.
12. Koshman L.V. Kul'turnoe prostranstvo russkogo goroda XIX – nachala XX vv. K voprosu o kreativnosti istoricheskoi pamyati. NB: Kul'tury i iskusstva. 2 2013. S 42-115.
13. Rost stroitel'stva v Kieve. Kievskaya mysl'. 9 iyulya 1914 g. str. 3.
14. Vil'shans'ka, O.L. Povsyakdenne zhittya m³st Ukra¿ni naprik³nts³ Kh²Kh — na pochatku KhKh st.: ºvropeis'k³ vplivi ta ukra¿ns'k³ nats³onal'n³ osoblivost³. Kiev : b.n., 2009. 172 c.
15. Naumov G. Byudzhety rabochikh goroda Kieva: Po dannym ankety, proizvedennoi v 1913 godu Obshchestvom ekonomistov i Remeslennoi sektsiei pri Kievskoi vystavke. Kiev: Tipografiya I.I. Chokolova: b.n., 1914 g. 100 s.
16. V teni. Yuzhnaya kopeika. 20 fevralya 1913 g. S. 2.
17. Pereezd v gorod. 1914 g., Zhizn' Volyni. S. 3.
18. Dorogovizna kvartir. Zhizn' Volyni. 1 avgusta 1914 g. S. 3.
19. Stydno! Yuzhnaya kopeika. 6 sentyabrya 1914 g. S. 2.
20. Averbakh, O. I. Zakonodatel'nye akty, vyzvannye voinoi 1914–1915 gg. T. 1. Petrograd : Tipografiya Petrogradskogo tovarishchestva pechatnogo i izdatel'skogo dela «Trud», 1916 g. 729 s.
21. Velika v³ina 1914–1918 rr. ³ Ukra¿na. Kiev: TOB «Vidavnitstvo “KL²O”», 2013. 784 s.
22. Prikhod'ko, V. P³d sontsem Pod³llya: spogadi. Ch. 2. V³nnitsya : TOV „Konsol'”, 2011. 416 s.
23. Stroitel'nyi krizis. Kiev. 19 sentyabrya 1914 g. S. 4.
24. Vesennie kartinki. Yuzhnaya kopeika. 12 aprelya 1915 g. S. 3.
25. Sidorov, A. L. Ekonomicheskoe polozhenie Rossii v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny. Moskva : Nauka, 1973 g. 656 s.
26. K stroitel'nomu sezonu. Kievskaya mysl'. 26 maya 1915 g. S. 3.
27. Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Vinnitskoi oblasti. F. D-230. Op. 1. D. 1605. 1017 l. g.
28. Lisii A.K. Pov³tove m³sto Pod³llya v buremn³ 1914 – 1917 rr. Narodi sv³tu ³ velika v³ina 1914 – 1918 rr.: mater³ali Vseukra¿ns'ko¿ naukovo¿ konferents³¿ 3-4 kv³tnya 2015 r. V³nnitsya: TOV «N³lan-LTD», 2015. S. 244-253.
29. Zhvanko L.M. Organ³zats³ya transportuvannya b³zhents³v Persho¿ sv³tovo¿ v³ini u tilov³ gubern³¿ Ukra¿ni (l³to – os³n' 1915 r.). Naukov³ prats³ ³storichnogo fakul'tetu Zapor³z'kogo nats³onal'nogo un³versitetu. 40 2014 g. S. 39-47.
30. ªsyun³n S.M. Dinam³ka chisel'nost³ naselennya m³st Pod³l's'ko¿ gubern³¿ v drug³i polovin³ Kh²Kh – na pochatku KhKh st. Naukov³ prats³ Kam'yanets'-Pod³l's'kogo derzh.pedagog³chnogo un³versitetu: ²storichn³ nauki . 07/2005 . T. 15. 2005 g. S. 391-397.
31. Bol'noi vopros. Zhizn' Volyni. 16 sentyabrya 1915 g. S. 3.
32. Kievskii gorodskoi golova. Yugo-Zapadnyi krai. 30 sentyabrya 1915 g. S. 2.
33. Kvartirnyi «golod». Zhizn' Volyni. 18 avgusta 1916 g. S. 3.
34. Kvartirnyi nalog. Slovo Podol³i. 22 oktyabrya 1918 g. S. 1.
35. Gol'denveizer A.A. Iz kievskikh vospominanii (1917–1921 gg.). Arkhiv Russkoi Revolyutsii. T. 6. Berlin: Izdatel'stvo I.V. Gessena, 1922. S. 161–303.
36. Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Vinnitskoi oblasti F. D-230. Op. 1. D. 1826. 23 l. g.
37. Obyazatel'nye postanovleniya…. Yugo-Zapadnyi krai. 4 avgusta 1915 g. s. 2.
38. Obyazatel'noe postanovlenie glavnogo nachal'nika Kievskogo voennogo okruga. Kievskie gubernskie vedomosti. 8 oktyabrya 1915 g. ¹ 105. S. 2.
39. Obyazatel'noe postanovlenie glavnogo nachal'nika Kievskogo voennogo okruga. Kievskie gubernskie vedomosti. 16 aprelya 1916 g. ¹ 43. S. 2.
40. Obyazatel'noe postanovlenie glavnogo nachal'nika Odesskogo voennogo okruga. Podol'skie gubernskie vedomosti. 5 sentyabrya 1915 g. ¹ 68. S. 2.
41. Obyazatel'noe postanovlenie glavnogo nachal'nika Odesskogo voennogo okruga. Podol'skie gubernskie vedomosti. 3 fevralya 1916 g. ¹ 10. S. 2.
42. Verstyuk, V. Direktoriya, Rada narodnikh ministriv Ukraïns'ko¿ narodno¿ respubliki 1918-1920. Dokumenti i materiali u 2 tomakh. T. 1. Kiev : Vidavnitstvo imeni Oleni Teligi, 2006. 450 s.
43. Direktoriya, Rada narodnikh ministriv Ukraïns'ko¿ narodno¿ respubliki 1918-1920. Dokumenti i materiali u 2 tomakh. T. 2. Kiev : Vidavnitstvo imeni Oleni Teligi, 2006. 482 s.
44. Dorogovizna i podokhodnyi nalog. Slovo Podolii. 17 oktyabrya 1918 g. S. 2.
45. Robinzon / Malen'kii fel'eton. Yuzhnaya kopeika. 13 iyunya 1916 g. S. 2.
46. Kamenetskie domovladel'tsy…. Podol'skii krai. 11 oktyabrya 1918 g. S. 4.
47. Izobretatel'nye domovladel'tsy. Slovo Podol³i. 1 oktyabrya 1918 g. S. 2.
48. Bol'noi vopros. Slovo Podol³i. 13 iyunya 1918 g. S. 3.
49. Proskurov. Slovo Podol³i. 29 iyunya 1918 g. S. 2.
50. Zasedanie soyuza kvartironanimatelei. Slovo Podol³i. 25 iyulya 1918 g. S. 1.
51. Institut rukopisei NBU imeni V. Vernadskogo. F. 91, ¹ 1. 1 l. g.
52. Kholodilin, Konstantin. War, housing rents, and free market: A case of Berlin's rental housing market during World War I. European Review of Economic History. gotovitsya k pechati.
53. Ascher, S. Die Wohnungsmieten in Berlin von 1880-1910. Erlangen : Carl Heymanns Verlag, 1917. 139 s.
54. Kvartirnyi vopros v Kieve. Yuzhnaya kopeika. 2 fevralya 1914 g. S. 3.
55. Prekrashchenie stroitel'nykh rabot. Kiev. 31 iyulya 1916 g. S. 4.
56. Pod kvartirnym gnetom. Yuzhnaya kopeika. 12 iyulya 1915 g. S. 2.
57. Chrezmernoe vzdorozhanie nedvizhimostei. Kiev. 12 iyulya 1916 g. S. 4.
58. Spros na krupnye doma. Kievskaya mysl'. 8 fevralya 1917 g. S. 2.
59. K voprosu o dorogovizne kvartir. Kievskaya mysl'. 29 sentyabrya 1915 g. S. 2.
60. Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Vinnitskoi oblasti. F. D-230. Op. 3. D. 73. 318 l. g.
61. Kvartirnyi vopros. Slovo Podol³i. 12 iyulya 1918 g. S. 1.
62. International Labour Office. European housing problems since the war 1914-1923. Geneva : Imprimeries réunies S.A., 1924 g. 484 s.
63. Brander, S. Wohnungspolitik als Sozialpolitik. Theoretische Konzepte und praktische Ansätze in Deutschland bis zum Ersten Weltkrieg. Berlin : Duncker & Humblot, 1984 g. 180 c.
64. Kholodilin, Konstantin i Meerovich, Mark. Housing policy in Soviet Russia and Germany between the two World wars: Comparative analysis of two systems. Journal of Urban History. 2016 g. 1-23 s.
65. Statistisches Jahrbuch für das Deutsche Reich. Berlin : Verlag von Puttkammer und Mühlbrecht, 1913 g. 598 c.
Link to this article
You can simply select and copy link from below text field.
