DOI: 10.25136/2409-7802.2021.2.35704

Abstract: The subject of this research is indicators that characterize the quality of municipal services rendered in accordance with the state (municipal) task in the sphere of youth policy. Special attention given to the analysis of state tasks approved on the federal and regional levels for budgetary (autonomous) institutions. The author examines the indicators that characterize the quality of municipal services in the sphere of youth policy as the foundation for assessing the achievement of publicly significant results in the context of the vector for improving the efficiency of spending budgetary funds. The article explores the problem of the absence of correlation between the quality of services rendered and the size of subsidy allocated for the implementation of state (municipal) task. The main conclusion consists in the statement that at the present day it is difficult to assess the achievement of publicly significant result in rendering state (municipal) services in the sphere of youth policy as a criterion for the appropriate use of subsidies for the fulfillment of the state (municipal) tasks within the framework of the activity of budgetary (autonomous) institutions. This is substantiated by the formal determination of indicators set by such institutions, which characterize the quality of the rendered municipal services and the absence of comprehensive legislative regulation in this sphere. The efficiency parameters of the conducted state youth policy are for the most part reflected through the quantitative indicators.

DOI: 10.25136/2409-7802.2021.1.34783

Abstract: The subject of this research is the practice of application of antimonopoly legislation of the Russian Federation to budgetary (autonomous) institutions, including in the context of restricting the established by the Section 3 of the Article 15 of the Federal Law No.135-FZ of July 26, 2006 “On Protection of Competition". The goal consists in identification and analysis of possible legal issues emerging due to the dual nature of the status of such institutions, substantiated by the conducted reform for increasing their economic independence. The article provides a scientific assessment of legal consequences of recognition of the budgetary (autonomous) institutions as economic entities for the purpose of application of antimonopoly legislation, taking into account the existing ban on combining functions of government branches and functions of economic entities, as well as authorizing the economic entities for the functions and rights of these branches, including state control and supervision bodies. Content of the concept of “function of the government branch” is reviewed. The author’s special contribution consists in evaluation of the situation, in which in the monopolized by public entity spheres related to the exercise of powers, are established  budgetary (autonomous) institutions that charge for rendering services required and essential for provision of state (municipal) services. The article views the mechanism of social procurement as market-oriented, a competitive way of rendering services using budget funds by both governmental and nongovernmental organizations. The novelty of this work lies in conclusion on the need to consider the principle of fair competition in case if the public legal entity decides to forgo the implementation of a new competitive method for selection of executants established by the law on social procurement, and use the traditional scheme of approval of the state (municipal) assignment.

DOI: 10.25136/2409-7802.2020.4.34612

Abstract: The subject of the research in this article is the restrictions provided for by the draft law submitted to the State Duma of the Russian Federation in relation to budgetary (autonomous) institutions engaged in procurement for the purpose of fulfilling state (municipal) tasks. The purpose of the study is to analyze these restrictions in the context of the reform carried out in relation to budgetary (autonomous) institutions aimed at increasing their economic independence. The article makes a scientific assessment of the legal possibilities of attracting co-executors for state and non-state organizations in the process of rendering state (municipal) services in connection with the adoption of Federal Law No. 189-FZ of July 13, 2020 "On State (Municipal) social order for the provision of state (municipal) services in the social sphere". The issue of the organization of law enforcement in the studied area, namely the use of the budget classification tool of the Russian Federation and other methods of identification of purchases, is considered. The author used such methods as comparison, generalization, system analysis, modeling and deduction. В  A special contribution of the author to the study of this topic is the formulation of general criteria that would enable institutions to attract performers (contractors) to perform works (provide services) in order to fulfill a state (municipal) task if the draft law under consideration is adopted. The main conclusion of this study is the need to bring to uniformity the regulatory regulation of the right to conduct procurement for the provision of public (municipal) services by both public and private organizations. This is due to the introduction of budgetary (autonomous) institutions into the competitive market along with other non-governmental organizations and giving them a certain economic freedom as a result of the initiated reform.

DOI: 10.7256/2306-9945.2017.6.25958

Abstract: The subject of this research is the creditor liability of a budgeting (authority) establishment before third parties in a situation of insufficient funding from a founding shareholder. According to the author, such situations result in limitation of financial independence guarantees granted by the law to establishments when the latter perform their expenditure budgeting (in relation to the disposal of funds from income-generating activities). In her article Fedoseeva carries out a scientific assessment of debt redemption mechanisms when such situations occur. The author of the article also analyzes the development of the institution of subsidiary responsibility through the ages as well as related contemporary laws on budgeting (authority) establishments. In the course of the research the author uses such methods of research as comparison, generalisation, systems analysis, modelling, and deduction. The author's special contribution to the topic is that she emphasizes the need to extend the boundaries of the founding shareholder subsidiary responsibility providing that such responsibility is fixed in the mandatory manner at the legal level and there is a direct connection between a debt occuring and the fact of underfunding.