Статья 'Консульские здания как образ иностранной архитектуры в городах Северо-Восточного Китая' - журнал 'Урбанистика' - NotaBene.ru
по
Journal Menu
> Issues > Rubrics > About journal > Authors > About the Journal > Requirements for publication > Editorial collegium > Peer-review process > Policy of publication. Aims & Scope. > Article retraction > Ethics > Online First Pre-Publication > Copyright & Licensing Policy > Digital archiving policy > Open Access Policy > Article Processing Charge > Article Identification Policy > Plagiarism check policy
Journals in science databases
About the Journal

MAIN PAGE > Back to contents
Urban Studies
Reference:

Consular Buildings as an Image of Foreign Architecture in the Cities of Northeast China

Smol'yaninova Tat'yana Anatol'evna

ORCID: 0000-0001-9328-5524

Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture and Urbanistics, Pacific National University

680035, Russia, Khabarovskii krai, g. Khabarovsk, ul. Tikhookeanskaya, 136, of. 506b

design.total@yandex.ru

DOI:

10.7256/2310-8673.2023.2.38331

EDN:

RVDKTJ

Received:

26-06-2022


Published:

05-07-2023


Abstract: The subject of the article is the buildings of consular offices in the cities of Northeast China. The object of the study is the architectural features of the preserved buildings of consular institutions. The author examines and analyzes consular institutions during the period of their appearance and the formation of the basic principles of their design at the end of the 19th - first half of the 20th century on the territory of Northeast China. The historical prerequisites for the appearance of consular institutions are considered. The principles of the placement of consular offices in the cities of Manchuria are highlighted, depending on their status, transport links, the location of administrative zones of settlements and the peculiarities of the layout of Chinese districts. In the course of the study, the peculiarities of the location of consular buildings were revealed depending on the urban planning position in the urban structure and their significance. The architectural appearance of consular facilities is briefly analyzed, which is presented in the form of a generalized table of graphic images. It presents the preserved representative objects of consular institutions and enlarged decorative elements. The compositional and stylistic features of the buildings of consulates are analyzed. The main conclusions of the study are that consular offices were important objects for the formation of compositional structures of cities, raising their prestige. The architecture of the consular buildings, reflecting the stylistics of different countries, filled the cities with stylistic flavor, increased the level of improvement of the territories adjacent to these buildings.


Keywords:

architecture, China, Manchuria, history, consulates, Northeast China, eclecticism, composition, architects, engineers

This article is automatically translated. You can find original text of the article here.

Introduction. The architectural heritage of European countries on the territory of Manchuria is of interest to scientists and historians who study the historical past of the cities of Northeast China. With the opening of cities for foreign trade and the formation of foreign settlements, the previously sparsely populated, but promising territory began to develop. Thus, on the territory of Manchuria, in particular, under the influence of the construction of the railway network, developed European settlements and cities began to appear on the basis of Chinese cities and towns, in which both Chinese and European populations lived side by side. The rapid pace of economic and, consequently, cultural development has led to the emergence of such facilities as hospitals, hotels, theaters, post offices, etc. Consular missions of foreign Powers began to be established to settle relations and conduct political negotiations. Diplomatic missions and consulates, including police stations and courts, were supposed to ensure the interests of the population of their countries in relations with representatives of other countries and the Chinese Government. It was at the beginning of the XX century that the stage of opening and establishing diplomatic missions took place, some of them have survived to the present in the historical buildings of Manchurian cities.

The purpose of the study is to identify the stylistic and compositional features of the architecture of buildings that housed consular offices during the late nineteenth and first half of the twentieth century. The subject of the study is the buildings of consular offices in the cities of Northeast China. The object of the study was the architectural features of the preserved buildings of consular offices and their location in the cities of Manchuria.

The research methodology includes the study of literature on the research topic, archival search, analysis of cartographic materials, historical photographs and full-scale research of objects. A summary of the collected materials and the results obtained are presented in the article. The research was based on empirical methods, such as observation and survey, on their basis a brief historical sketch of the objects of observation was compiled. The theoretical basis is based on analysis, classification and generalization. Comparative analysis of the objects allowed us to develop a classification of influencing factors on the choice of placement of consulates in the city structure. This made it possible to identify patterns of representativeness of objects depending on the urban planning position of objects. Generalization of the stylistic features of the objects under consideration made it possible to identify the main stylistic directions of the countries of the consular offices.

The theoretical basis of the research is the work of Russian and foreign scientists covering certain aspects described in this article. In literary and Internet sources devoted to this topic, it was possible to identify three types of placement of consular offices in the cities of Northeast China. The results obtained are the basis for further study of the architecture of consular offices in the cities of Manchuria.

The architecture of consular institutions has not been considered in full by almost anyone and therefore is of interest primarily from the point of view of architectural features of this type of buildings, in particular planning and spatial. In Russia, N. P. was one of the first to become interested in the architecture of Manchuria and its analysis. Kradin [1, 2] and S. S. Levoshko [3], whose works consider the legacy of Russian and European engineers. The architecture of the KVZhD of the late XIX – first third of the XX century is devoted to the dissertation of T. Yu . Troitskaya [4]. These works were the first and significant step in the study of the Russian architectural heritage and their influence on the formation of the visual appearance of the historical cities of Manchuria. In addition, the works of N. E. Kozyrenko, Hongwei Yang, A. P. Ivanova [5, 6, 7] and Yu. V. Ordynskaya [8] are of interest. Chinese researchers are engaged in compiling catalogs of preserved and lost buildings [9], for example, in the work "The Condensed Music" [10], fairly detailed drawings of some preserved objects are presented. In foreign Internet sources, it was possible to identify information about the lost projects and their authors, for which it was partially possible to establish the history of the objects to which the consulates were located. Periodicals published in Harbin and Sydney, Russian-language newspapers and magazines such as Zarya, Rupor, Forward and Polytechnic were also used as sources. The materials of the AVPRI, RGIA, and GAHK funds played an important role in the study.

As a result of the analysis of consular facilities, it was found that during the period under review, consular offices of such countries as Russia, Great Britain, Japan, USA, Italy, Belgium, the Netherlands, Germany, Austria-Hungary, Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Spain, Portugal, and Switzerland, Latvia, Czechoslovakia were opened on the territory of Manchuria, Poland. In total, 64 such institutions were identified, which are represented by 86 objects, of which 20 institutions were specially built for consular needs.

Placement of consular offices. With such a rapid pace of settlement of the territory and the formation of foreign quarters, there is still selectivity in the selection of objects for the placement of consular offices. Here I would like to highlight three main aspects that reveal this moment. Firstly, the emphasis is on the urban planning position of the site or object in relation to important points of attraction, which include the railway, and in particular the railway station, which can be seen in cities such as Harbin, Manchuria, Changchun and Qiqihar. This is due to the fact that these cities were in the zone of influence of Russia, the administrative center of these cities is closely connected with the railway junction, which affects the choice of the location of the consulate, namely closer to the border of the railway tracks and the station, as this has a great impact on the development and functioning of consular institutions. This type of city has a developed administrative and commercial hub with trading houses and cultural facilities that allow consuls to carry out their functions.

The second type of placement includes the choice of an object in the administrative centers of European quarters, which can be traced in the cities of Dalian, Shenyang and Jilin. This is typical for the already established hub cities, the formation of which continued far from the historical Chinese centers. These cities emerged during a period of rapid development of productive and commercial forces that developed quite quickly in accordance with the needs and opportunities of economic growth of cities. In them, as a rule, there is a rapid expansion of the European urban center, where the most significant buildings in the city are located: administrative buildings, shopping facilities, restaurants and hotels, residential buildings and public facilities. When choosing a site or facility for consular offices, the proximity to the administrative center of the city and the main transport arteries, as well as proximity or proximity to friendly countries or their consular missions were taken into account.

As a third type of placement, cities formed on the basis of old Chinese centers and their suburbs are considered, which often grow so far beyond the natural boundaries of the city that it becomes completely unclear how the city will develop. These include Dandong, Yingkou, Teling, Jilin. The town-planning position of consular offices in such cities can be completely different.

In choosing objects for consular offices, in addition to the town-planning situation, not only the architectural characteristics of the objects, but also the buildings located nearby, their functional content and proximity to consulates of other countries had to be taken into account. In accordance with this, when placing new consular offices, it was decided to use only those buildings that were distinguished by architectural expressiveness and presentability, while a number of requirements were imposed on the size of the possessions and the autonomy of the site usually occupying strategic importance in the urban structure. This was done in order to ensure unhindered access to their facilities, which emphasizes the need for the use of office, technical and residential premises of employees. To a greater extent, this is reflected in the choice of objects in the cities of Harbin and Dalian, since most of the buildings were located in the administrative district of the city, occupying mansions built according to individual projects.

Brief description of the buildings of consulates. Historical processes in Northern China, which took place from the end of the XIX to the second half of the XX century, as already noted above, led to the formation of consular offices in different countries. During this period, the addresses of consular offices were repeatedly changed, and many were completely lost. Such buildings stood out against the general background of urban development, as evidenced by the preserved historical photographs and panoramas of cities. The architecture of the buildings often reflected the spirit of the country they represented. Both Russian and foreign engineers were engaged in the design of facilities on the territory of Manchuria, in particular consulates, among which K. H. can be distinguished. Denisova, A. I. Stepanova, Yu. P. Zhdanova, K. K. Iokish, S. A. Vincent, M. A. Troyanovsky, Kazy-Giray, yap. architects Shiro Mihashi and Shiro Mitsuhashi, as well as various foreign architectural bureaus, primarily Japanese and British [11, 12, 13]. Stylistic diversity is noted not only on the facades, but also in the architectural and compositional organization of buildings and the planning zoning of consular sections. The main trends in the architecture of consular institutions peculiar to Russia and a number of other European countries during the late nineteenth and first half of the twentieth century were the prevailing stylistic trends of the metropolis, which were transferred to East Asia. In general, consulates represent various styles – from neoclassicism and Renaissance to neo-modern. The analysis of the figurative solution of these consular buildings revealed a number of compositional techniques for organizing their facades (Table 1). For classic mansions, for example, a symmetrical composition of facades relative to the central axis, an unpaired number of window openings, accentuation with porticos, risalites, rustication, belts, the texture of the base is characteristic. Eclectic buildings, in particular those made with modernist motifs, are distinguished by the asymmetric composition of facades, the presence of bay windows, the active use of color and texture. With the angular location of such objects in urban development, they are often accentuated by turrets, various forms of domes and tents with a spire, creating spatial compositions of urban development.

 

Table 1. Architectural appearance of consular buildings

Изображение выглядит как текст, внешний, здание, небо  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как здание, внешний, белый, старый  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как внешний, здание, старый, белый  Автоматически созданное описание

Consulate General of the Russian Empire in Harbin,

architect K. H. Denisov, designer S. V. Ignatius

The building of the Consulate General of the USSR in Harbin, the authorship is not established

The building of the Consulate General of Japan in Harbin, architect Y. P. Zhdanov

Здание консульства в Харбине, построенное в 1930 году.

Изображение выглядит как внешний, здание  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как внешний, старый, трава, белый  Автоматически созданное описание

The building of the British Consulate General in Harbin, arch. Herbert Ashmead

The building of the Italian Royal Consulate in Harbin, authorship presumably P. I. Gibello-Socco

The building of the Consulate of the Russian Empire in Changchun, the authorship is not established

Изображение выглядит как текст, внешний, дорога, дом  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как текст, старый, белый, черный  Автоматически созданное описание

https://i2.kknews.cc/SIG=237obm3/ctp-vzntr/ERq4qUr8jIjI1J.jpg

The complex of buildings of the consulate of Manchukuo in Changchun, the authorship is not established

The building of the Japanese Consulate in Jilin, yap. arch. Shiro Mihashi

The complex of buildings of the Consulate of Manchukuo in Jilin, the authorship is not established

Изображение выглядит как текст, внешний, старый  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как здание, внешний, дом, старый  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как текст, трава, внешний, старый  Автоматически созданное описание

The building of the Japanese Consulate in Telin, the authorship is not established

The complex of buildings of the Japanese Consulate in Shenyang, Mitsuhashi Architectural Bureau

UK Building Complex in Shenyang, British Construction Bureau in Shanghai

Изображение выглядит как здание, внешний, правительственное здание  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как белый, старый, черный, винтажный  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как текст, здание, внешний, улица  Автоматически созданное описание

The complex of buildings of the German Consulate in Shenyang, the authorship is not established

The building of the French Consulate in Shenyang, the authorship is not established

The complex of buildings of the Japanese Consulate in Yingkou, arch. Shiro Mitsuhashi

Изображение выглядит как текст, здание, внешний, старый  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как текст, внешний, старый, белый  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как текст, внешний, старый, белый  Автоматически созданное описание

The building of the USSR Consulate in Dalian, the authorship is not established

The building of the US Consulate in Dalian, the authorship is not established

The British Consulate building in Dalian, arch. Herbert Ashmead

Automatically created description" width="199" height="126" />

Изображение выглядит как текст, старый, внешний, черный  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как текст, дерево, внешний, здание  Автоматически созданное описание

The building of the German Consulate in Dalian, the authorship is not established

The building of the consulates of the United States, Great Britain and Japan in Dandong, the authorship is not established

The complex of buildings of the Consulate of Japan in Dandong, the authorship is not established

It should be noted the importance of sculptural and decorative elements in the artistic and compositional construction of the facades of consulates and their importance in enhancing the stylistic effect. First of all, these are details and elements using relief images of people and animals (Table. 2), clear geometric shapes and figures, ornaments of plant origin. Friezes are formed with ornamental motifs, windows are decorated, tympanums of pediments and portals are filled, blades, pilasters and entablatures are decorated. The architectural decor of the buildings of the consular offices was an important link in the formation of the architecture of Manchuria.

Table 2. Sculptural and decorative elements of facades of consular buildings

Изображение выглядит как текст, внутренний, ванная, раковина  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как здание, внешний, дом, окно  Автоматически созданное описание    Изображение выглядит как здание, дом, правительственное здание  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как здание, внешний, арка, камень  Автоматически созданное описание

German Consulate in Dalian

Consulate of Manchukuo in Changchun

Russian Consulate in Yingkou

Изображение выглядит как текст, внешний, дерево, старый  Автоматически созданное описание

Automatically created description" width="106" height="158" />Изображение выглядит как здание  Автоматически созданное описание

Japanese Consulate in Yingkou

USSR Consulate in Harbin

Изображение выглядит как здание, внешний, старый, окно  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как текст, кирпич  Автоматически созданное описание

Изображение выглядит как небо, здание, внешний  Автоматически созданное описание

Russian Consulate in Changchun

U.S. Consulate in Dalian

Consulate of Japan in Shenyang

Изображение выглядит как текст, монитор, набор  Автоматически созданное описание

 

Italian Consulate in Harbin

Russian Consulate in Harbin

French Consulate in Harbin

Conclusion. A brief analysis of the architectural features of consular buildings in the cities of Manchuria during the late nineteenth and first half of the twentieth century allows us to conclude that this type of structures is important for the formation of compositional structures of cities, increasing its prestige. The architecture of the consular buildings, reflecting the stylistics of different countries, fills the cities with a stylistic flavor, a high level of improvement of the territories adjacent to these buildings. The consular buildings that have been preserved to this day represent a valuable historical and architectural heritage that is subject not only to study, but also to preservation as historical and cultural monuments.

References
1. Krdain, N. P. (2001). Harbin—Russian Atlantis. Khabarovsk: Khvorov (in Russian).
2. Krdain, N. P. (2010). Harbin—Russian Atlantis. Khabarovsk: Khabarovsk Regional printing house (in Russian).
3. Levoshko, S. S. (2003). Russian architecture in Manchuria. The end of the 19th – the first half of the 20th century. Khabarovsk: Chastnaya kollektsiya. (in Russian).
4. Troitckaia, T. Iu. (2003). Features of the architecture of the Sino-Eastern Railway: the end of the 19th – the first third of the 20th centuries [unpublished PhD in Architecture dissertation]. Novosibirsk State Academy of Architecture and Art. (in Russian).
5. Ivanova, A. P. (2014). Foreign influences in the architecture of China and Indochina. 1860–1960. Khabarovsk: Pacific National University Publisher. (in Russian).
6. Kozyrenko, N. E., Yang, Hongwei & Ivanova, A. P. (2015). Harbin's Urban Heritage. Khabarovsk: Pacific National University Publisher. (in Russian).
7. Kozyrenko, N. E., Yang, Hongwei & Ivanova, A. P. (2015). Harbin's architectural Heritage. Pacific National University Publisher. (in Russian).
8. Ordynskaia, Iu. V. (2019). Features of the formation of urban planning systems in the border area of Russia and China [unpublished PhD in Architecture dissertation]. Moscow Architectural Institute. (in Russian).
9. Chang, Huaisheng (Ed.) (1990). Harbin architecture. Harbin: Heilongjiang Science and Technology Press. (in Chinese).
10. Li, Xiaotao (Ed.) (2005). The Condensed Music. Overview of protected constructions in Harbin. Beijing: China Construction Press. (in Chinese).
11. Kradin, N. P. & Bazilevich, M. E. (2020). Architects and engineers of the Far East. Creative activity of graduates of the capital's educational institutions – in Transbaikalia, Yakutia, the Amur Region, Primorye and China. Khabarovsk: Khabarovsk Regional printing house (in Russian).
12. Kradin, N. P. (2018). Russian engineers and architects in China. Khabarovsk: Khabarovsk Regional printing house (in Russian).
13. Bazilevich, M. E. & Kim, A. A. (2021). Russian engineers—builders of banks in Manchuria. Project Baikal, 68. 147–151. doi: 10.51461/projectbaikal.68.1816

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The article "Consular buildings as an image of foreign architecture in the cities of Northeast China" submitted for publication is a bibliographic and historical study (including the study of archival materials) of the compositional structures and stylistic features of consular buildings in the period of the late nineteenth and first half of the twentieth century. The purpose of the study: to study and describe the stylistic features of the architecture of the buildings in which the consular offices were located. The subject of the study correlates with the purpose of the study, and follows from the text: "... buildings of consular offices in the cities of Northeast China." The object of the study is the architectural features of the preserved buildings of consular offices and their location in the cities of Manchuria. Unfortunately, the methodology of the study is not described, one has only to guess: historical, structural or comparative analysis? The relevance of the study is: the study of consular buildings for further analysis and classification. The theoretical basis of the research is the work of Russian and foreign scientists covering certain aspects described in this article. In the literature and Internet sources devoted to this topic, it was possible to identify three types of placement of consular offices in the cities of Northeast China. The scientific novelty follows from the text: "... are the basis for further research of the architecture of consular institutions in the cities of Manchuria." The style is scientific, corresponds to the normalization of speech, facts are accurately and fully explained, cause-and-effect relationships in concepts are shown. The structure of the text is correct, the structural elements of the text are present in the study. Content. The study presents: an introduction (which consists of elements of text presentation – subject, object, purpose, relevance, scientific novelty), the main part (Placement of consular offices, Brief description of consulate buildings) and the conclusion of the study (which should be distinguished as a "Conclusion"). The paper contains 2 tables. The research of the bibliography on this topic is presented by 13 sources, among them there are: 11 Russian authors and 2 foreign authors. The work presents an appeal to opponents, studies the works of N. P. Kradin, S. S. Levoshko, T. Y. Troitskaya, N. E. Kozyrenko, Hongwei Yang, A. P. Ivanova and Y. V. Ordynskaya, etc. The presented conclusions correspond to the objectives of the study. Comments on the work: add the methods and methodology of the study, highlight the section "Conclusion", indicate references to [11, 12, 13] authors in the bibliography. The article is intended for a wide range of readers interested in art, restoration and foreign architecture, architectural and artistic heritage of consular buildings in China. From the point of view of architecture and art, the article will arouse the reader's interest among students of architectural and art history universities, various figures in the field of historiography, archival affairs, engineers, practitioners in the field of urban planning and cartography, architects.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The article is devoted to the problematization of the study and preservation of the architectural heritage of consular buildings in the cities of Northeast China. The author logically substantiates the features of architectural solutions of consular buildings related to the translation of cultures of different countries. These features emphasize the value of architectural heritage sites and indicate their specific function in the architectural landscape of cities in Northeast China. The purpose of the study ("identification of stylistic and compositional features of the architecture of buildings in which consular offices were located during the late nineteenth and first half of the twentieth century") was achieved by the author. The subject of the study ("buildings of consular offices in the cities of Northeast China") is considered in a sufficiently comprehensive manner. The object of the study ("architectural features of the preserved buildings of consular offices and their location in the cities of Manchuria") has been supplemented with new empirical data, which are visualized in a selection of photo illustrations. The author studied the placement of consular offices in the architectural landscape of cities in Northeast China and gave a brief description of a sample of architectural heritage sites, presenting tables of visual typology and classification of buildings and sculptural and decorative elements of their facades to confirm his judgments. The appeal to empirical sources is justified and allows the author to logically emphasize the importance of this type of structures for the formation of compositional structures of cities in Northeast China. Although the author's conclusion "about the prestige" of the analyzed objects in urban landscapes remained insufficiently substantiated. Of course, there are grounds for such a position, but they are not given in the text of the article. Due to this circumstance, such a conclusion looks biased and discriminatory in relation to the traditional autochthonous architecture of cities in Northeast China. I would like to draw the author's attention to the need to clarify his position or, on the contrary, avoid such categorical judgments when finalizing the article. The research methodology is based on the author's synthesis of well-known standard techniques (historical-bibliographic and historical-biographical methods, search and selection of archival sources, analysis of cartographic materials, historical photographs and field studies of objects, observations). The generalization of the collected materials and the results obtained was logical and reasonable, which allowed the author to identify a number of stylistic features of the objects under consideration and compare them with the main stylistic trends in the architecture of the countries of the representative offices of consular institutions. The relevance of the work is due to the need to develop theoretical foundations for the preservation of the architectural heritage of consular buildings in the cities of Northeast China. The scientific novelty consists in the visual typology of buildings and design elements of their facades presented by the author, in the author's selection of research objects, in the formulation of the problem of preserving the architectural heritage of consular buildings in the cities of Northeast China. The style is scientific. The structure of the work corresponds to the logic of presenting the results of scientific research. According to the content, there are small comments on the coordination of the members of the proposals, which the author can easily correct (for example, "draw a conclusion about the importance of this type of structures for the formation of compositional structures of cities, increasing its prestige"), it is necessary to carefully read the text in order to literary edit such inaccuracies. The bibliography fully reflects the problem area of the study, is designed in accordance with the requirements of the editorial board and GOST. Of course, the list could have been significantly strengthened by analyzing foreign literature over the past 5 years, although this disadvantage did not affect the quality of the presented research results. The appeal to the opponents is correct and quite sufficient. The article will certainly arouse the interest of the readership of the journal "Urbanistics". It can be published after a little revision, taking into account the recommendations of the reviewer.
Link to this article

You can simply select and copy link from below text field.


Other our sites:
Official Website of NOTA BENE / Aurora Group s.r.o.