Статья 'Реконструкция ранней этнической истории якутского племени "Жархан" на основе этнонимии, устной традиции и тотемических представлений' - журнал 'Genesis: исторические исследования' - NotaBene.ru
по
Journal Menu
> Issues > Rubrics > About journal > Authors > About the Journal > Requirements for publication > Editorial collegium > The editors and editorial board > Peer-review process > Policy of publication. Aims & Scope. > Article retraction > Ethics > Online First Pre-Publication > Copyright & Licensing Policy > Digital archiving policy > Open Access Policy > Article Processing Charge > Article Identification Policy > Plagiarism check policy
Journals in science databases
About the Journal

MAIN PAGE > Back to contents
Genesis: Historical research
Reference:

Reconstruction of the early ethnic history of the Yakut tribe "Jarkhan" on the basis of ethnonymy, oral tradition and totemic ideas

Vinokurov Aleksandr Danilovich

ORCID: 0000-0001-8925-8750

Junior research fellow at IHRISN SB RAS

677000, Russia, Republic of Sakha (Yakutia), Yakutsk, Petrovsky str., 1, office 410

ad.vinokurov@yandex.ru

DOI:

10.25136/2409-868X.2023.12.69436

EDN:

GBIAUO

Received:

20-12-2023


Published:

27-12-2023


Abstract: The article is devoted to the early history of the Yakut tribe "Jarkhan", which was one of the main ethnic components involved in the formation of the Vilyui group of Yakuts. Previously, historical and genealogical information was transmitted orally with help of historical legends. The end of the XIX – the middle of the XX centuries marks a qualitatively new period in the formation of the written tradition of the genealogy of the Yakut people associated with the painstaking source studies, collecting and research work of G.V. Ksenofontov, S.I. Bolo, A.A. Savvin, G.U. Ergis, etc. We have made an attempt to show the process of segmentation of the Jarkhan clans and the formation of new tribal groups by compiling a nomenclature of the generic composition. The study of the generic composition allows us to imagine the processes of movement and settlement of genera, renaming, merging and formation of new ones. The purpose and objectives of the research are to systematize and interpret the materials of the oral genealogical tradition, legends and archival documents. The methodological basis of the research is based on the basic principles of historical science - the principle of historicism and the principle of objectivity. The principle of historicism is important for conducting genealogical research, as it allows us to trace the segmentation of large tribal groups into small ones. General scientific and historical methods (historical-comparative, historical-typological, source analysis) were used as additional research methods. The novelty of the research lies in the systematization of the tribal composition and the introduction into scientific circulation of previously unpublished documents of the National Archive of the RS(Ya) revealing the tribal composition. Based on the studied material, it is concluded that oral historical traditions and pedigrees represented the central core in the structure of historical knowledge among the Yakuts. Conceptually, genealogical traditions were formed from real genealogy and unreal, which is basically a structure-forming fictional genealogy (within the boundaries of tribal communities). The result of the work performed is the preparation of the nomenclature of the Yakut generic composition. We also found that the Yakuts had common, group and individual totems. Along with this, the practice of changing the historical totem to a new one associated with a new habitat has been revealed.


Keywords:

totemism, pedigrees, genealogy, family history, local communities, historical anthropology, tribal structure, ancestor cult, archival documents, legends

This article is automatically translated. You can find original text of the article here.

 The Zharkhans are one of the largest tribal groups that took part in the formation of the Yakut people. Oral folk tradition traces their ancestry back to the legendary ancestress Nyirbakaan, who was the wife of Kangalas toyon Munnan Darkhan. At the same time, the preserved archival documents designate the Zharkhans as an integral part of the Kangalassians. In this regard, in this study we have attempted to show the process of segmentation and formation of new tribal groups.

The first written information of the Russian Cossack explorers localizes the Yarkanskaya parish near the mouth of the Sinaya River (Fig.1) and they are included in the composition of the Kangalas group of clans and tribes [2, p. 371]. The book of the yasak collection for 1648-1649 contains the names of yasak collectors Treki Ilgiev, his sons Togurai, Tokhtotoy, Balatchi Trekin, Tyulyak Syusergin, who paid yasak in the Yakut prison, and Bulgudak Ugdarov, Tarkai Barkanov, Tarbuk Barkanov, Orgus Chachuev, Ivak Yemkonov, Tyumuk Ivakov, Mogchor Chyukuev, Sarchikan Byrkanov , Tureika Ugdarova paid yasak in Olekminsky prison [4, pp.703-705, pp.755-756]. Of the above-mentioned persons, the name of Tarkai Barkanov can be correlated with the name of the folklore character Tarkaaya Byrkyaa uol, the son of Byrkyaa Bootur, the grandson of Nyrbakaan.

Figure 1. Map of the settlement of the Yakut clans in the 17th century

A cycle of legends about Nyirbakaan and her descendants has been preserved among the Yakuts of the Vilyuisk and central group of uluses. The main concept of this legend tells that after the defeat of the tumats of the Tunguska tribe "Nyrba?aat" (in other sources - tumatka), one girl named Nyrbakaan managed to get to the modern location of Yakutsk and became the wife of the Kangalas ancestor Munnan Darkhan. Three sons were born from this marriage: Byrkyaa Bootur, Toyuk Bulgudakh and Bosho Balgetii. It is worth noting that perhaps this marriage had a political and dynastic background. Further, it tells about the forced relocation of Nyirbakaan's sons to the Vilyu River in connection with the difficult relationship of the brothers with Tygyn Darkhan's half-brother, the eldest son of Munnan Darkhan [9, p.21].

Further, the storyline says that when the brothers Byrkyaa Bootur and Toyuk Bulgudakh escaped from Tuimaada, they left their paralyzed brother Bosho? Balgetiya at the Nuoraldyn river, which is a tributary of the Sinaya River. Paying attention to the geographical localization of the Zharkhans at the mouth of the Sinaya River, according to the evidence of the documents of the XVII century yasach collection, it can be assumed that the Boskho of Balgetii was left with relatives who lived here [3, p.237]. In accordance with this, it can be assumed that by the time of the arrival of Russian explorers in the territory of central Yakutia, according to folklore and archival information, there were two local groups of Zharkhans:

1. The Zharkhans, led by Trek Ilgiev, who lived along the Sinaya River of the Khangalassky ulus (confirmed by archival sources);

2. Zharkhans from the Nyirbakaan suite who lived in the Tuimaad valley of Yakutsk (according to folklore sources).

After the exodus from central Yakutia, the Zharkhans settled the territory of modern Suntar and Nyurbinsky uluses and a separate genus remained in the basin of the Olekma River. According to the data of the audit tales of 1795 and the All-Russian Agricultural and Land Census of 1917, a table of the settlement of Zharkhans was prepared indicating the separated villages [11, pp.786-787] (Table 1).

Table 1. Settlement of the Zharkhan naslegs with indication of the separated naslegs

The name for 1795

The name for 1917

Separated from each other (in different years)

1. Suntarsky and Khochinsky uluses (modern Suntarsky ulus)

1.1.

1st Zharkhan parish of the Olekminsky commissariat

1st Zharkhan nasleg of Suntarsky ulus

1. Kugdarsky

2. Butukai

3. Tokosovsky

4. Tyubyai

5. Tyubyai-Zharkhansky

1.2.

2nd Zharkhan parish of Olekminsky commissariat

2nd Zharkhan nasleg of Khochinsky ulus

1. Arylakhsky (Tysakyssky)

2. Meitskiy (Matchaginsky);

3. Upper Meitskiy nasleg

1.3.

The 3rd Zharkhan parish of the Olekminsky commissariat

3rd Zharkhan nasleg of Khochinsky ulus

1. Allaginsky (Suntarsky);

2. Bakamdinsky;

3. Hadan

4. Kubalakhsky

5. Akkyrasovsky

2. Markhinsky ulus (modern Nyurbinsky ulus)

2.1.

1st Zharkhan parish of Verkhovilyuysky ulus

1st Zharkhan nasleg of Markhinsky ulus

1. Tarkai;

2. Khorulinsky;

3. Tyumyuksky;

4. Tongo-Konuysky (Tysakyssky)

2.2.

2nd Zharkhan parish of Verkhovilyuysky ulus

2nd Zharkhan nasleg of Markhinsky ulus

1. Bestyakhsky;

2. Tylykinsky;

3. Kukakinsky.

4. Andaybytsky.

3. Olekminsky ulus

3.1.

Yarkhan clan of the 2nd Meitskaya volost of the Olekminsky commissariat

Yarkhan clan of the 2nd Meit nasleg of Olekminsky ulus

-

4. Verkhneviluysky ulus

4.

Zharkhan clan of the Batulin parish of the Verkhovylyuysky Commissariat

Onogochchutsky district of Verkhnevilyuysky ulus

 

5.

The Syalyadyarsky family of the Orget volost of the Verkhovilyuysky Commissariat

Orgetskiy nasleg of Verkhnevilyuysky ulus

 

5. Srednevilyuysky ulus (modern Vilyuysky ulus)

5.

Zharkhansky family of the Orget volost of the Srednevilyuysky commissariat

Orgetskiy nasleg of Srednevilyuysky ulus

 

The above table is significantly supplemented by the second table listing the generic composition (Table 2), thanks to which it is possible to track the process of fragmentation and formation of new genera and offshoots.

Table 2. Nomenclature of the generic composition of the Zharkhan naslegs

Name

Childbirth

1. Suntarsky and Khochinsky (modern Suntarsky) uluses

1st Zharkhan nasleg (maternal and separated nasleg)

1.

1st Zharkhan nasleg

Borisovsky, Koboloksky, Tokosovsky, Boturovsky. 

2.

Kugdarsky

Myndai, Butovsky, Tokosovsky.

3.

Butukaysky

Butukaysky.

4.

Tyubyai

Alekseevsky, Zhurkuyansky, Milyakinsky.

5.

Tyubyai-Zharkhansky

Oyun-Usovsky, Boturovsky, Zharkhansky, Urasalakhsky

2nd Zharkhan nasleg (maternal and separated nasleg)

1.

2nd Zharkhan nasleg of Khochinsky ulus

Oyun-Usovsky, Kakansky, Tysakyssky, Telegeyansky, Khapchygyrsky, Tyusyumyalsky, Legoysky, Khorulinsky, Akarovsky, Kononovsky

2.

Meitskiy (Matchaginsky)

Arylakhsky, Meiksky

3.

Verkhne-Meitskiy

Meiksky

4.

Arylakhsky (Tysakyssky)

Tysakyssky, Torbossky, Zhampinsky, Khapchygyrsky

The former 3rd Zharkhan nasleg (separated nasleg)

1.

Bakamdinsky

Danube, Bakamdinsky, Maldzheysky

2.

Hadan

Hadan, Bordon, Kyramdinsky, Kubalakhsky

3.

Kubalakhsky

Khadan, Kubalakhsky

4.

Allaginsky (Suntarsky)

Abaginsky, Sillaysky, Pavlovsky, Aydaginsky, Akkyrasovsky

5.

Akkyrasovsky

Akkyrasovsky

2. Markhinsky (modern Nyurbinsky) ulus

1st Zharkhan nasleg (maternal and separated nasleg)

1

1st Zharkhan (maternal)

Golovinsky, Syalyadyarsky, Tyumyuksky, Etisilyakhsky, Tysakyssky.

2

Tarkai

Mereisky, Ortho-Ibyaksky, Pavlovsky, Boltorinsky.

3

Khorulinsky

Khorulinsky, Torbokhovsky, Ospeksky, Jarzygnassky.

4

Tyumyuksky (part of the Tyumyuk family)

Tyumyuksky.

5

Tongo-Konuisky (part of the Tysakis family)

Tysakyssky, Ekya, Saryla, Khantayys.

2nd Zharkhan nasleg (maternal and separated nasleg)

1.

2nd Zharkhan (maternal)

1st Saltan, 2nd Saltan, Tylykinsky, 1st Kispyansky, 2nd Kispyansky, Kemperkeysky, Khoroboysky, Megezhetsky.

2.

Tylykinsky

Khalgaryassky, Kylakynsky, Inyaksky, Kuibaksky.

3.

Bestyakhsky

Andaybytsky, Lenge, Lebiysky, Shestakovsky, Zakharovsky, Kipchyrakinsky.

4.

Andaybytsky (separated from Bestyakhsky nasleg)

Andaybyt

5.

Kukakinsky

Kyrasinsky, Lakhsyrsky, Kukakinsiy

3. Olekminsky ulus

2nd Meit (Kyllakh) nasleg

1.

2nd Meit (Kyllakh) nasleg

Yarkhan family

4. Verkhnevilyuysky ulus

1.

Onogochchutsky district of Verkhnevilyuysky ulus

Zharkhan family

2.

Orgetskiy nasleg of Verkhnevilyuysky ulus

The Syalyadyarsky family

5. Srednevilyuysky ulus (modern Vilyuysky ulus)

1.

Orgetskiy nasleg of Srednevilyuysky ulus

Zharkhan family

Of the above genera, representatives of the Tongo-Konui (formerly part of the 1st Zharkhan) nasleg of the Markhinsky ulus lived most closely to central Yakutia, who lived in the Tongo-Kuunu River basin [5, l.2], the Syalyadyarsky genus in the Tobuya River basin of the Orget nasleg of the Verkhneviluysky ulus [6, l.2], the Zharkhan genus of the Orget nasleg The Srednevilyuysky ulus [8, L.2] and the Yarkhan clan of the Olekminsky ulus [7, L.1]. The presence of Zharkhan clans as part of other tribal groups may indicate the settling of part of the Zharkhans when the bulk of their tribesmen move towards the Vilyu River.

As a totemic patron, the Vilyui Zharkhans, as part of the Kangalas tribal union, had an eagle [10, p.165]. Nyrbakaan Tarkaaya's grandson had a son named Borulloo (translated from the Yak.yaz. – white-tailed eagle). At the same time, as the Olekminsky Yarkhans had a swan as a totemic animal, perhaps this fact indicates the interpenetration of totemic ideas from the Meitans to the Yarkans [12, p. 246].

Over the years, thanks to the efforts of researchers and local historians, oral versions of the family tree schemes of the Zharkhans were recorded. It is worth noting that these schemes are confirmed by the materials of audit fairy tales and metric books. As an example, the genealogy of the Golovinsky family (Kuluba a?atyn uuha) of the 1st Zharkhan nasleg of the Markhinsky (Nyurbinsky) ulus compiled by G.I. Vasiliev-Wastaayy from the words of the older generation of relatives (names from archival documents are given in parentheses) can serve as an example:

1. Munnan Darkhan (Myndyak) + Nyrbakaan;

2. Yrya Byrkyaa;

3. Tarkaayy (Tarkai Barkanov);

4. Borulloo;

5. Archancha;

6. Boccujar (Bolchuyar Arhantin);

7. Bayam (Bayam Bolchuyarov, after the baptism of Nikolai Sleptsov).

Subsequently, the family of Nikolai Sleptsov's ulus head was divided into two branches during the division of the 1st Zharkhan and Tarkai naslegs: 1. The Golovinsky genus as part of the 1st Zharkhan nasleg; 2. The Pavlovsky genus of the Tarkai nasleg [1, pp.3-4].

Thus, based on folklore and archival sources, an attempt to reconstruct the early ethnic history of the Zharkhans allowed us to get a more complete picture of the specifics of the development of this tribal community at the turn of the XVII-XX centuries. As a result of the study, the places of settlement and ancestral composition were identified, pedigrees and totemic representations were studied. 

References
1. Vasilyev-Bylastaayy, G.V. (1999). Kuluba aҕatyn uuha. Yakutsk: YSU Publishing House.
2. Dolgikh, B.O. (1960). The clan and tribal composition of the peoples of Siberia in the 17th century. Moscow: Publishing House of the USSR Academy of Sciences.
3. Historical legends and stories of the Yakuts. In 2 vols. T. 1. (1960). Leningrad: Publishing House of the USSR Academy of Sciences.
4. Materials on the history of Yakutia in the 17th century: (documents of yasak collection). At 3 hours. Part 2 (1970). Moscow: Nauka.
5. National Archives of the Republic of SAKHA (Yakutia). F. I343, Op. 4, vol. 1, D. 130.
6. National Archive of the Republic of SAKH (Yakutia). F. I343, Op. 4 v.2, D. 461.
7. National Archive of the Republic of SAKH (Yakutia). F. I343, Op. 5, D. 55.
8. National Archive of the Republic of SAKH (Yakutia). F. I343, Op. 7, D. 100.
9. Stepanov, N.T. (1991). Nyirbakaan udjuordara: (bylyrgy seһenner uonna kepseenner). Yakutsk: Publishing house YSC SB RAS.
10. Popov, G.N. (2009). Works Vol.2: Past of Yakutia: collection. doc. and materials on the history of the Yakut Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic. Yakutsk.
11. Patkanov, S. (1912). Statistical data showing the tribal composition of the population of Siberia, language and clans of foreigners: (based on data from special development of the 1897 census material). St. Petersburg: Printing house “Sh. Bussel”.
12. Folklore of the Olekma Yakuts. (2021). Yakutsk: Alaas.

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

Review of the article "Reconstruction of the early ethnic history of the Yakut tribe "Zharkhan" based on ethnonymy, oral tradition and totemic representations" The subject of the study is indicated in the title and explained in the text of the article. The research methodology is based on the principles of objectivity, science, and historicism. Historical-chronological, historical-comparative, historical-genetic, etc. were used in the work. methods. Relevance. At present, the Turkic-Mongolian peoples have increased their interest in the study of clans and tribal unions in ethnogenesis and in the history of peoples. This is largely due to the processes of archaization in the context of transformational changes in society observed since the end of the twentieth century. The author writes that "the Zharkhans are one of the largest tribal groups that took part in the formation of the Yakut people and their ancestry goes back to the legendary ancestress Nyirbakaan," while folklore sources and written sources differ on the issue of whether this is a separate genus or the Zharkhans are an integral part of the Kangalas family. The author in this article makes an attempt to "show the process of segmentation and formation of new tribal groups" among the Yakuts. The scientific novelty of the work is determined by the formulation of the problem and the objectives of the study. The novelty is also determined by the fact that the work was prepared on the basis of an existing set of folklore and archival documents. Style, structure, content. The style of work is scientific with descriptive elements. The structure of the work as a whole is logically built. At the beginning of the article, the author writes about the purpose of the research and the tasks. Next, he compares folklore data about the genus and writes that the Yakuts have preserved a cycle of legends about the ancestress of the Nyirbakaan family and her descendants. "The main concept of this legend tells that after the defeat of the tumats of the Tunguska tribe "Nyrba?aat" (in other sources - tumatka), one girl named Nyrbakaan managed to get to the modern location of Yakutsk and became the wife of the Kangalas ancestor Munnan Darkhan." Folklore legends also speak about the place of localization of the genus. In Russian sources of the middle of the XVII century, some representatives of this genus are mentioned who paid yasak and the author correlates the name of one of them (Tarkai Barkanov) with the name of the folklore character Tarkaaya Byrkyaa uol, the son of Byrkyaa Bootur, the grandson of Nyrbakaan. Based on folklore and historical sources, the author identifies two local groups of Zharkhans. The article analyzes the formation of ancestral settlements (naslegs) of Zharkhans in different districts of Yakutia. The author also analyzes the generic composition and tracks the process of formation of new genera and naslegs. In the conclusion of the article, the author provides conclusions on the topic. The text of the article is logically structured and consistently presented. The text is provided with two tables and one drawing (a map of the settlement of the Zharkhans in the XVII century). The bibliography of the article consists of 12 sources (these are archival documents of their National Archive of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia), collections of folklore materials in Russian and Yakut languages, works on the history of Yakutia, fundamental work of Dolgikh B. O., devoted to the tribal and tribal composition the peoples of Siberia in the XVII century, based on statistics on the ancestral composition and number of Yakuts at the end of the XIX century.). The bibliography is designed according to existing rules. The appeal to the opponents is presented at the level of the collected information on the research topic and the results obtained. The bibliography of the work is also an appeal to the opponents. Conclusions, the interest of the readership. The work will be of interest to historians, folklorists and other specialists interested in the ancestral composition of the Yakuts and other peoples of Siberia.
Link to this article

You can simply select and copy link from below text field.


Other our sites:
Official Website of NOTA BENE / Aurora Group s.r.o.