Статья 'Индивидуально-психологические предикторы профессионального стресса врачей-хирургов, на примере травматологов-ортопедов' - журнал 'Психолог' - NotaBene.ru
по
Journal Menu
> Issues > Rubrics > About journal > Authors > About the Journal > Requirements for publication > Editorial collegium > Editorial board > Peer-review process > Policy of publication. Aims & Scope. > Article retraction > Ethics > Online First Pre-Publication > Copyright & Licensing Policy > Digital archiving policy > Open Access Policy > Article Processing Charge > Article Identification Policy > Plagiarism check policy
Journals in science databases
About the Journal

MAIN PAGE > Back to contents
Psychologist
Reference:

Individual psychological predictors of occupational stress of the surgeons on the example of orthopedic surgeons

Kekteeva Yuliya Igorevna

Assistant, the department of Psychotherapy, the faculty of Clinical Psychology and Social Work, Pirogov Russian National Research Medical University of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation

117997, г. Москва, ул. Островитянова, д. 1

psihoteraphy@mail.ru
Gardanova Zhanna Robertovna

Doctor of Medicine

Professor, Head of the Department of Psychotherapy, the faculty of Clinical Psychology and Social Work, Pirogov Russian National Research Medical University of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation

117997, г. Москва, ул. Островитянова, д. 1

psihoteraphy@mail.ru
Chistiakova Natalia Viktorovna

PhD in Psychology

Docent, the department of Pedagogy and Pedagogical Psychology, the faculty of Clinical Psychology and Social Work, Pirogov Russian National Research Medical University of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation

117997, г. Москва, ул. Островитянова, д. 1

dik_dog@list.ru

DOI:

10.25136/2409-8701.2022.1.37132

Received:

17-12-2021


Published:

11-01-2022


Abstract: The practical activity of surgeons is an essential part of providing in-patient and out-patient medical aid in the Russian Federation. The orthopedic surgeons are at high risk of maladjustment due to the negative impact of job-related stress factors., and thus are more sensitive to psychoemotional strains in comparison with other professional groups. The effectiveness of the corrective effect of surgical treatment is closely associated with the risk of medical malpractice. Comprehensive assessment of psychoemotional state of the orthopedic surgeons reveals the subjective level of stress resistance as a health-saving factor in the context of rendering medical aid in the in-patient facilities. The goal of this research lies in determination of predictors of emotional exhaustion among the orthopedic surgeons due to their professional activity. The sampling involved 75 male staff members of the department of Traumatology and Orthopedics at the Central Clinical Hospital of the Russian Academy of Sciences and National Pirogov Medical Surgical Center. Assessment is conducted on the functional state, anxiety level, and peculiarities of coping behavior of the respondents, using a tested psychodiagnostic toolset and SPPS Statistics 28.0.1.0. As a result, it is revealed that psychoemotional well-being of orthopedic surgeons affects their overall behavior and the effectiveness of professional activity. Description is given to predictors of the symptoms of personality neuroticism caused by emotional exhaustion related to neuropsychiatric loads and risk of development of the chronic fatigue syndrome. The author establishes a proclivity for asthenia, emotional distress, rigidity, low activity level, and impaired mood among the orthopedic surgeons working in the in-patient care facilities.


Keywords:

emotional state, stress, stress-factors, surgeon, traumatologist-orthopedist, anxiety, coping-behavior, mental well-being, activity, behavior strategy

This article is automatically translated. You can find original text of the article here.

introduction

Surgeons are exposed to a high level of stress in their daily work and are at risk of social maladaptation against the background of changes and the occurrence of functional disorders. By the nature of their professional activity, they experience diverse emotions, and, unfortunately, of a negative nature, which are associated with an intensive work schedule, performing a large amount of work, experiencing situations of failure and disappointment in the case of the progression of patients' illness and deterioration of the prognosis of treatment. At the same time, in the conditions of an aggravated epidemiological situation, they are afraid of getting sick themselves, suffer from uncertainty in the development of their career and lack of sufficient clinical practice in their specialty [8]. In general, emotional reactions can have a negative impact on the nature of interaction with the patient when providing medical care [4]. Strengthening and deepening of asthenic emotions against the background of experiencing distress reduces the subjective level of stress resistance in the workplace in solving professional tasks [1; 6].

Orthopedic traumatologists have to work in increasingly tightly regulated conditions, taking into account the time deadline [9]. New protocols of surgical treatment, the inability to adjust the work schedule, floating meals and rest time, bureaucratic requirements leave an imprint on the emotional state of specialists. Continuous operation contributes to changing the speed of manipulations when performing high-tech operations. Modern medical knowledge is being actively developed and updated, and surgeons of all profiles must constantly support them and develop themselves. These changes often occur so quickly that by the time specialists acclimatize to one innovation, objective reality imposes other requirements. Unfortunately, orthopedic traumatologists are increasingly disappointed in their profession, which leads to professional mistakes and unethical behavior in the doctor?patient communication system.

In addition, orthopedic traumatologists are morally unprepared to work in modern conditions, when new skills are acquired and familiar, but not relevant, methods of work are not used. At the same time, new functional roles are being formed that are not directly related to surgical treatment in inpatient settings. High-tech medical care in surgery has reoriented orthopedic traumatologists to a population-based model of medical care. 

Orthopedic traumatologists are subject to stress in situations that arise outside the field of interaction with the patient. They must perform administrative duties, in addition to their main activities. Performing unusual tasks provokes a stress reaction, and the constantly changing working environment predisposes to a high degree of strain on the body's resources. Often specialists try to cope with the loads on their own, resorting to maladaptive coping strategies through emotional detachment, self-isolation and denial. Ineffective coping behavior has a negative impact on the mental state and provokes pathological reactions to the chronic effects of professional stress factors.

Orthopedic traumatologists demonstrate lower psychoemotional well-being compared to other professional groups [10; 11]. They tend to have an increased level of anxiety due to intense workload, high competitiveness, chronic lack of sleep, administrative pressure [3]. The problem of studying professional stress factors related to the psycho-emotional well-being of orthopedic traumatologists is important for the preservation of mental health and the effectiveness of medical care.

 OBJECTS AND METHODS OF RESEARCH

The theoretical and methodological basis of the study is the personality-oriented approach of B.D. Karvasarsky, as well as the conceptual model of psychological support for the professional development of the doctor B.A. Yasko [2; 6]. The study involved 75 male patients, employees of the Department of Traumatology and Orthopedics on the basis of the FSBI CCB of the Russian Academy of Sciences and GUZ GKB No. 1 named after N.I. Pirogov of the Moscow Health Committee. The assessment of the functional state, the level of anxiety and the features of coping behavior of the subjects were carried out using the approved psychodiagnostic tools and the statistical data analysis package SPPS 28.0.1.0. Comparative analysis of individual differences in the functional state and features of the emotional sphere of the personality of the subjects was carried out using the anxiety scale of C.D. Spielberger in the adaptation of Y.L. Khanin, the coping test of R. Lazarus in the adaptation of L.I. Wasserman, as well as the questionnaire "Well–being – activity - mood" by V.A. Doskin et al. [5]. In order to assess the level of emotional exhaustion associated with the professional activities of orthopedic traumatologists, the "burnout" test was used by K. Maslach and S. Jackson in the adaptation of N.E. Vodopyanova.

RESEARCH RESULTS

The average age of the subjects is 39.4+5.2 years. The majority of orthopedic traumatologists demonstrated low indicators of well-being ? 32 people (42.6%), activity ? 25 people (33.4%), mood – 18 people (24%), which is more than half of the sample. Less than half of the respondents have average indicators of mental state: the scale of well–being – 46 people (36.8%), the scale of activity - 53 people (42.4%), the scale of mood – 49 people (39.2%). Using visually presented analog histograms, the following values were obtained for low?level indicators of the diagnosed scales: well?being ? 2.14 ± 0.58 points (60.2%), activity - 2.02 ± 0.6 points (52.8%), mood - 1.6 ± 0.58 points (48.4%).

Individual-level values of subjective anxiety of traumatologists-orthopedists are in the zone of potential risk. High reactive anxiety prevails in 34 specialists (45.7%), and the average is observed in 21 doctors (28%). The optimal level of stress tolerance was recorded only in 20 subjects in the sample, which was 26.6% of the total sample.

The analysis of the results of the test of R. Lazarus' coping strategies showed that the studied group has a significant superiority of the average level indicators on the main scales. In the "Confrontation" scale ? 32 subjects with an average level (42.6%), in "Self–control" ? 15 people (20%), in "Distancing" - 28 people (37.3%). The average range of indicators of most coping strategies indicates a borderline state in the self-assessment of the own stress response of orthopedic traumatologists. This may be due to a pronounced focus on finding an adaptive solution in the event of an emergency problem situation, with limited resource potential.

A high degree of emotional exhaustion was detected in 15% of the subjects. The average subscale values were: 21.8+10.2 points in the assessment of affective lability, 11.6+7.3 points in terms of the severity of negativism, 31.2+11 points regarding the reduction of professional skills, respectively. The obtained results indicate the predisposition of the subjects to insomnia, irritability and sharpness in communication when interacting with colleagues and patients. In addition, the experience of dissatisfaction with professional activity, responsibility for the life and health of patients, low motivation and general fatigue provoke negative reactions at the psychosomatic level of the subject's organization.

Correlation analysis revealed the presence of significant links between reactive anxiety and well-being (r emf=-0.64 at p?0.01), between activity and self-control (r emf=0.59 at p?0.01), as well as between the level of personal anxiety and professional reduction (r emf=0.49 at p?0.01). High reactive anxiety can be considered as an indicator of predisposition to emotional exhaustion when choosing maladaptive coping strategies. In general, there was a direct interaction of the main subscale values of mental health of traumatologists-orthopedists with a pronounced tendency to asthenia, emotional instability, rigidity, low activity and reduced mood with the risk of developing chronic fatigue syndrome. Based on the factor analysis using the Varimax-rotation method, two main factors were identified in assessing the mental health of orthopedic surgeons, which explain 54% and 33% of the total variance. The first factor "Risk of neuroticism" included such indicators as low well-being and activity (-0.637 and -0.642, respectively), high subjective anxiety (0.736) and emotional exhaustion (0.723). The second factor "Occupational stress" includes a tendency to use confrontation (0.536), flight (0.519) and distancing in behavior (0.503) with pronounced professional reduction (0.628). The neuropsychic load of professional activity triggers a characteristic individual-typological symptom complex of personality neuroticism with a high sensitivity to external influences, which can negatively affect the effectiveness of medical care.

conclusion

The present study reveals the features of the subjective perception of professional stress factors of orthopedic traumatologists in modern conditions. The results obtained confirm that the level of occupational stress has increased dramatically recently. The state of emotional exhaustion among orthopedic traumatologists is most clearly manifested in situations of neuropsychiatric stress directly related to the threat to the life and health of the patient. The considered aspects of psychological well-being demonstrate the existence of a connection between the state of mental health and the choice of adaptive strategies of coping behavior in solving professional tasks in surgical treatment. In conditions of multitasking professional activity, orthopedic traumatologists are potentially prone to mental health deterioration. The level of stress resistance is sharply reduced in people with low functional status due to high workloads, while they are distinguished by pronounced reactive anxiety, negativism and low empathy against the background of reduction of professional achievements. The results obtained indicate that orthopedic traumatologists are at risk of emotional exhaustion and need specialized corrective measures.

References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The paper "Individual psychological predictors of occupational stress of surgeons, using the example of orthopedic traumatologists" is presented for review. The identification of professional factors that are associated with the psychoemotional well-being of orthopedic traumatologists is significant for psychological science and practice. Surgeons are subject to high levels of stress in their daily work and are at risk of social maladjustment against the background of changes and the occurrence of functional disorders. The author, based on the results of domestic and foreign studies, identifies negative conditions, noting the importance of the problem and the need to preserve the mental health of medical specialists. Surgeons operate on an intensive work schedule, perform a large amount of work, and are in a situation of uncertainty about the patient's condition and the progression of his disease. Moreover, the aggravated epidemiological situation creates strictly regulated conditions, new surgical treatment protocols, the need to work continuously and in rapidly changing circumstances. Conducted foreign studies, to which the author refers, have shown that orthopedic traumatologists show lower psycho-emotional well-being in comparison with other professional groups. Therefore, the consideration of individual psychological predictors of occupational stress of surgeons is relevant, which is justified in the introduction by the author. The subject and purpose of the study were not formulated in the work, and the tasks were not defined. This is a significant disadvantage that requires correction. The author is recommended to finalize and show the methodology of the scientific work carried out. It is noted that "the theoretical and methodological basis of the study is the personality-oriented approach of D.B. Karvasarsky, as well as the conceptual model of psychological support for the professional development of the doctor B.A. Yasko." This is correct, so careful revision of the methodology should not cause difficulties. The author conducted an independent study. The sample consisted of 75 male employees of the Department of Traumatology and Orthopedics on the basis of the Federal State Budgetary Budgetary Institution of the Central Committee of the Russian Academy of Sciences and the State Medical Institution No. 1 named after N.M. Pirogov in Moscow. Considerable attention was paid to: assessment of the functional state, the level of anxiety and the features of coping behavior; comparative analysis of individual differences in the functional state and features of the emotional sphere of the personality of the subjects; identification of the level of emotional exhaustion associated with the professional activities of orthopedic traumatologists. The work carried out made it possible to identify low indicators of well-being, activity and mood of doctors, as well as high values of the individual-level indicator of subjective anxiety. Among the study participants, specialists with a high degree of emotional exhaustion were identified. The results indicate a predisposition of the subjects to insomnia, irritability and sharpness in communication when interacting with colleagues and patients. In addition, the experience of dissatisfaction with professional activity, responsibility for the life and health of patients, low motivation and general fatigue provoke negative reactions at the psychosomatic level of the subject's organization. The research conducted by the author showed significant results. However, the article did not present generalized conclusions and the scientific novelty of the study was not substantiated. The author concluded by noting that "the results obtained confirm that the level of occupational stress has increased dramatically recently." It is recommended to substantiate the scientific novelty, paying attention to personal scientific contribution to the development of this topic, and formulate detailed and specific conclusions. The bibliographic list includes sources on the research topic. But the share of textbooks and lecture courses is significant. These sources of literature need to be replaced, since they are not scientific works. In addition, it is recommended to finalize the bibliographic list, since some descriptions lack the necessary data (for example, the year of publication is not in the first source, etc.). Despite the highlighted comments, the work makes a good impression. This article is relevant, of interest to the reading audience and, after revision, can be recommended for publication.
Link to this article

You can simply select and copy link from below text field.


Other our sites:
Official Website of NOTA BENE / Aurora Group s.r.o.