Статья 'Вопросы правового обеспечения несменяемости судей в деятельности Высочайше учрежденной комиссии для пересмотра законоположений по судебной части' - журнал 'Genesis: исторические исследования' - NotaBene.ru
по
Journal Menu
> Issues > Rubrics > About journal > Authors > About the Journal > Requirements for publication > Editorial collegium > The editors and editorial board > Peer-review process > Policy of publication. Aims & Scope. > Article retraction > Ethics > Online First Pre-Publication > Copyright & Licensing Policy > Digital archiving policy > Open Access Policy > Open access publishing costs > Article Identification Policy > Plagiarism check policy
Journals in science databases
About the Journal

Публикация за 72 часа - теперь это реальность!
При необходимости издательство предоставляет авторам услугу сверхсрочной полноценной публикации. Уже через 72 часа статья появляется в числе опубликованных на сайте издательства с DOI и номерами страниц.
По первому требованию предоставляем все подтверждающие публикацию документы!
MAIN PAGE > Back to contents
Genesis: Historical research
Reference:

Issues of Legal Support of Irremovability of Judges in Activity Performed by the Highest Established Commission for Reviewing Court System Regulations

Shchedrina Yuliya Vladimirovna

Doctor of History

Associate professor, the department of entrepreneurial and labour law, Kursk State University

305000, Russia, Kurskaya oblast', g. Kursk, ul. Radishcheva, 33

shchedrinaj@gmail.com
Другие публикации этого автора
 

 

DOI:

10.7256/2306-420X.2014.6.13697

Review date:

11-11-2014


Publish date:

25-11-2014


Abstract.

As object of research the standards of the project of new edition of the Establishment of judicial establishments developed within functioning of Most highly founded commission for revision of statutes by judicial part (N. V. Muravyyov's Commissions) regulating the principle of an irremovability of judges act. In article specifics of legal regulation and practice of realization of the principle of an irremovability of judges at the beginning of the 1890th are considered, the course of discussions within work of the Commission on a question of standard fixing of the principle of an irremovability is lit, short stories of the project regarding legal regulation of the specified principle are analyzed. During research by the author the following methods of research were applied: chronological, historical and typological, comparative and legal, comparative-historical and others. In article the conclusion which settled in science that activity most high was directed to the founded commission for revision of statutes by judicial part on elimination of the principle of an irremovability is challenged; it is proved that updating of provisions of Judicial charters for elimination from the legislation of the mechanism of a nemenyaemost absolute, negatively affecting structure of the judicial case became a task of the Commission. The conclusion is drawn that the objective was solved only partially by reorganization of system of the bodies considering questions of the early termination of powers of judges without their soglasiyaa, and insignificant expansion of the bases for the early termination of powers.

This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here .

References
1.
Vsepoddanneishii doklad upravlyayushchego ministerstvom yustitsii, tainogo sovetnika Murav'eva o peresmotre zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti // Vysochaishe uchrezhdennaya komissiya dlya peresmotra zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti. Ob''yasnitel'naya zapiska k proektu novoi redaktsii uchrezhdeniya sudebnykh ustanovlenii. T. 1. Ch. 1. Vvedenie. Glavnye osnovaniya predpolagaemogo sudoustroistva. SPb., 1900. S. 65-82.
2.
Vysochaishe uchrezhdennaya komissiya dlya peresmotra zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti // Zhurnal ministerstva yustitsii. 1898. Noyabr'. № 9. S. 37-40.
3.
Vysochaishe uchrezhdennaya komissiya dlya peresmotra zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti. Ob''yasnitel'naya zapiska k proektu novoi redaktsii Uchrezhdeniya sudebnykh ustanovlenii. T. I. Ch. 1. Vvedenie. Glavnye nachala predpolagaemogo sudoustroistva. SPb: Senatskaya tipografiya, 1900. 86 s.
4.
Vysochaishe uchrezhdennaya komissiya dlya peresmotra zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti. Ob''yasnitel'naya zapiska k proektu novoi redaktsii uchrezhdeniya sudebnykh ustanovlenii. T. II. Ch. II. Obshchie voprosy sudoustroistva (glavy I-XVI). SPb: Senatskaya tipografiya, 1900. 471 s.
5.
Vysochaishe uchrezhdennaya komissiya dlya peresmotra zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti. Otdel I . Zhurnal №10. Zasedaniya 10 i 23 noyabrya 1895 g. «O poryadke uvol'neniya i peremeshcheniya dolzhnostnykh lits sudeiskogo zvaniya v svyazi s voprosom o sudeiskoi nesmenyaemosti» // Trudy Vysochaishe uchrezhdennoi komissii dlya peresmotra zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti. T. 8. Zhurnaly V otdela Komissii. № 1-25, 23 oktyabrya 1894 g. – 11 marta 1899 g. SPb: Tip. Prav. Senata, 1899. 10 c.
6.
Vysochaishe uchrezhdennaya komissiya dlya peresmotra zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti. Proekt novoi redaktsii Uchrezhdeniya sudebnykh ustanovlenii. SPb: Senatskaya tipografiya, 1900. 220 s.
7.
Korotkikh M. G. Samoderzhavie i sudebnaya reforma 1864 g. v Rossii. Voronezh: Izd-vo Voronezhskogo universiteta, 1989. 185 s.
8.
Osoboe mnenie chlena komissii A. F. Koni o poryadke uvol'neniya sudei // Vysochaishe uchrezhdennaya komissiya dlya peresmotra zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti. Ob''yasnitel'naya zapiska k proektu novoi redaktsii uchrezhdeniya sudebnykh ustanovlenii. T. II. Chast' II. Obshchie voprosy sudoustroistva (glavy I-XVI). SPb: Senatskaya tipografiya, 1900. Prilozhenie 13. S. 61-63.
9.
Osoboe mnenie chlena komissii I. P. Zakrevskogo ob otmene garantii nezavisimosti sudei // Vysochaishe uchrezhdennaya komissiya dlya peresmotra zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti. Ob''yasnitel'naya zapiska k proektu novoi redaktsii uchrezhdeniya sudebnykh ustanovlenii. T. II. Chast' II. Obshchie voprosy sudoustroistva (glavy I-XVI). SPb: Senatskaya tipografiya, 1900. Prilozhenie 12. S. 59-60.
10.
Osoboe mnenie chlenov komissii K. A. Mal'chevskogo i N. N. Shreiberga po st. 297 proekta // Vysochaishe uchrezhdennaya komissiya dlya peresmotra zakonopolozhenii po sudebnoi chasti. Ob''yasnitel'naya zapiska k proektu novoi redaktsii uchrezhdeniya sudebnykh ustanovlenii. T. II. Chast' II. Obshchie voprosy sudoustroistva (glavy I-XVI). SPb: Senatskaya tipografiya, 1900. Prilozheniya. S. 55-58.
11.
Pobedonostsev K. P. Predvaritel'nye zamechaniya o novom ustroistve sudebnykh uchrezhdenii // Predvaritel'nye zamechaniya o plane i glavnykh osnovaniyakh ustava o sudoustroistve. Materialy po sudebnoi reforme v Rossii 1864 g. T. 17. Soobrazheniya raznykh lits o preobrazovanii sudebnoi chasti (1861-1862). B/m, b/g. 26 s.
12.
I. Polozhenie o zemskikh uchastkovykh nachal'nikakh; II. Pravila ob ustroistve sudebnoi chasti v mestnostyakh, v kotorykh vvedeno oznachennoe Polozhenie; III. Vremennye pravila o volostnom sude i IV. Pravila o poryadke privedeniya v deistvie Polozheniya o zemskikh uchastkovykh nachal'nikakh: Vysochaishe utverzhdennye 12 iyulya 1889 g. // Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiiskoi imperii. Sobr. III. T. IX. № 6196.
13.
Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi istoricheskii arkhiv. F. 560. Op. 21. D. 629. L.1-1ob.
14.
Rovinskii D.A. O dolzhnostnykh litsakh sudebnogo vedomstva // Predvaritel'nye zamechaniya o plane i glavnykh osnovaniyakh Ustava o sudoustroistve. Materialy po sudebnoi reforme v Rossii 1864 g. T. 17. Soobrazheniya raznykh lits na preobrazovaniya sudebnoi chasti (1861-1862 gg.) S. 29-33.
15.
Soveshchanie starshikh predsedatelei i prokurorov sudebnykh palat o sudebnoi kar'ere // Zhurnal ministerstva yustitsii. 1895. № 6. S. 67-74.
16.
Shchedrina Yu. V. Nesmenyaemost' sudei v Rossii vo vtoroi polovine 60-kh kontse 80-kh gg. XIX v.: zakonodatel'noe zakreplenie i praktika realizatsii // Pravo i politika. 2012. № 9. C. 1618-1627.
Link to this article

You can simply select and copy link from below text field.


Other our sites:
Official Website of NOTA BENE / Aurora Group s.r.o.
"History Illustrated" Website