'- : ' - ' ' - NotaBene.ru
Journal Menu
> Issues > Rubrics > About journal > Authors > About the journal > Requirements for publication > Editorial collegium > Peer-review process > Policy of publication. Aims & Scope. > Article retraction > Ethics > Online First Pre-Publication > Copyright & Licensing Policy > Digital archiving policy > Open Access Policy > Open access publishing costs > Article Identification Policy > Plagiarism check policy > Editorial board
Journals in science databases
About the Journal

MAIN PAGE > Back to contents
Philosophical Thought
Reference:

Central Asian Region and its Community Culture: Dialectics of the Unity and Variety

Nurulla-Khodzhaeva, Nurulla-Khojaeva Nargis Talatovna

Doctor of Philosophy

research assistant at Institute of Oriental Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences

107031, Russia, g. Moscow, ul. Rozhdestvenka, 12

Nargis.nurulla@gmail.com

 

 

DOI:

10.7256/2306-0174.2014.4.11806

Review date:

17-03-2014


Publish date:

1-4-2014


Abstract: The increasing number of modern western researchers tell about community recognition, trying to define and formulate a definition and a role of this institute. This tendency was put earlier, in works of founders of a modernism (beginning from Durkheim, Weber, Marx and others). In publications of present kommunitarist a community put forward as the main anti-pillbox to alienation and tyranny, and as a key element of "good society". Though the sociocultural contents of this theory, also as well as its methodological instructions on which it is based, are related to all social to sciences, nevertheless, those are interested in communal development in particular who try to separate from political disagreements, and to accent the research priorities in touch people, on ability to cooperate. To Central Asian to a community interest is still minimum. Though throughout the long history the community of Central Asia skillfully balanced on ability to keep cultural and linguistic diversity and necessary for development of the person an autonomy. That is the communal culture of the region didn't project antagonism between variety and an autonomy. The present national states of the region, often copy options of liberal individualism, or try to keep formalistic collectivist approaches of the Soviet sample. However in such context relevance of uniform history, social structures and region communications is missed. The communal institute (without active state "assistance") is capable to stop process of an individualization of society, and to present culture of Central Asia in more reasonable and correct key.


Keywords: community, Central Asia, culture, balance, settled, nomads, cooperation, 'culture of shame', Islam, individualism
This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here .

References
1.
Chatterdzhi, P. Sokrovennaya religioznaya filosofiya Indii [Tekst] / P. Chatterdzhi. M.: Sfera, 2001. S. 55.
2.
Istoriya Kazakhskoi SSR s drevneishikh vremen do nashikh dnei [Tekst] / V 5 t. T. 1. Pervobytnoobshchinnyi stroi. Plemennye soyuzy i rannefeodal'nye gosudarstva na territorii Kazakhstana. Alma-Ata: Nauka KazSSR, 1977. S. 101.
3.
Flier, A. Ya. Kul'turologiya dlya kul'turologov: uchebnoe posobie dlya magistrantov i aspirantov, doktorantov i soiskatelei, a takzhe prepodavatelei kul'turologii [Tekst] / Andrei Yakovlevich Flier M.: Akademicheskii proekt, 2000. s. 25
4.
Shpengler, O. Zakat Evropy [Tekst] / Osval'd Shpengler. M.: Eksmo, 2009. S. 109.
5.
Cm.: Benedict, R. Patterns of Culture [Text] / R. Benedict. Boston and New York: Houghton Miffin Co, 1934. R. 210.
6.
Masanov, H. Kontseptsiya sovremennoi gosudarstvennoi vlasti nasledie kochevnikov [Elektronnyi resurs] http://forum.turan.info/showthread.php?t=2249. Zaglavie s ekrana. Data obrashcheniya: [16.05.2011].
7.
Maverannákhr (arab.ما وراء النهر‎‎ Ma Wara' un-Nahr, bukval'no zarech'e), izvesten takzhe pod nazvaniyami Transoksiana (lat. Transoxiana) i Vararud (pers.فرارود‎ Varārud) istoricheskaya oblast' v Tsentral'noi Azii. Nazvanie poyavilos' vo vremya arabskogo zavoevaniya VIIVIII vekov, etim terminom stali oboznachat' region mezhdu Amudar'ei i Syrdar'ei.
8.
Semirech'e: na tyurkskikh yazykakh Zhetysu (kaz. Zhetsu), Dzheti-suu (kirg. zhetisuu) geograficheskaya i istoricheskaya oblast' v Tsentral'noi Azii. Sem' glavnykh rek, ot kotorykh proizoshlo nazvanie regiona: Ili, Karatal, Bien, Aksu, Lepsi (Lepsy, Lepsa), Baskan, Sarkand.
9.
Sitnyanskii, G. Yu. Problema reintegratsii byvshego SSSR s tochki zreniya istoricheskogo naslediya narodov Evrazii [Tekst] / G.Yu. Sitnyanskii // Vestnik Evrazii. 1996. 2. C. 160171.
10.
Shariat ((arab.شريعة‎‎ ) nabor pravovykh, moral'no-eticheskikh i religioznykh standartov, prinyatykh v islame.
11.
Yasy zakony, prinyatye Chingiskhanom. Tore sakral'noe pravo tyurkomongol'skikh plemen.
12.
Viko, D. Osnovaniya novoi nauki ob obshchei prirode natsii [Tekst] / Dzh. Viko. M.: Kiev: REFL-book, ISA, 1994. S. 327.
13.
Yasavi, Khodzhi Akhmed. Khekmat [Tekst] / Khodzhi Akhmed Yasavi. Alma-Aty: Iskusstvo, 1995.
14.
Masanov, N. E. Kazakhskaya politicheskaya i intellektual'naya elita: klanovaya prinadlezhnost' i vnutrieticheskoe sopernichestvo / [Tekst] Nurbulat Edigeevich Masanov // Vestnik Evrazii. 1999. 1. S. 46.
15.
Feodal'noe obshchestvo Srednei Azii i ego torgovlya s Vostochnoi Evropoi v XV vv. [Elektronnyi resurs] http://kungrad.com/history/doc/torg/1/ Zaglavie s ekrana. Data obrashcheniya: [03. 08.2011].
16.
Golenishchev-Kutuzov, N. I. Tvorchestvo Dante i mirovaya kul'tura [Tekst] / Il'ya Nikolaevich Golenishchev-Kutuzov. M.: Nauka, 1971. S. 150.
17.
Sm.: Blanchard, I. The Middle Ages: A Concept too Many? Inaugural Lecture, Edinburgh, 1996 / Blanchard I [Elektronnyi resurs] http://www.ianblanchard.com/CEU/paper1.pdf. Zaglavie s ekrana. Data obrashcheniya: [30.01.2012].
18.
Sm.: Amin, M., Qazi, R. Efficiency of Infiltration Galleries as a Source of Water in Arid Lands [Text] / Amin M., Qazi R. // Water International. 1983. Vol. 8. Issue 4. P. 39.
19.
Feodal'noe obshchestvo Srednei Azii i ego torgovlya s Vostochnoi Evropoi v XV v. [Elektronnyi resurs] http://kungrad.com/history/doc/torg/1/ Zaglavie s ekrana. Data obrashcheniya: [03. 08.2011].
20.
Sm.: Goldberg, E. Khatima Nadhariya wa-Tarikhiya: al-Mujtama' al-Madani [Text] / Goldberg, E. In Al-Dimuqratiya fi al-sharq al-Awsat, Ahmed Abdulla, Ed. Cairo: Markaz al-Guil, 1995. R.320.
21.
Cm.: McChesney, R.D. Central Asia: Foundation of change [Text] / R.D. McChesney. NJ: Darwin Press, 1996. 204 p.
22.
Crone, P., Hinds M. Gods Caliph: Religious authority in the first centuries of Islam [Text] / Crone P., Hinds M. Cambridge UK, 1986. R. 94.
23.
Skrynnikova, T. D. Kharizma i vlast' v epokhu Chingiskhana [Tekst] / T.D.Skrynnikova. M.: Vostochnaya literatura, 1997. S. 47.
24.
Sm.: Masanov, N. E. Kochevaya tsivilizatsiya kazakhov: osnovy zhiznedeyatel'nosti nomadnogo obshchestva [Tekst] Nurbulat Edigeevich Masanov. Almaty: Sotsinvest; M.: Gorizont, 1995. 320 s.
25.
Krader, L. The origin of state among the Nomads of Asia [Text] / L. Krader // Pastoral Production and Society. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1979. P. 201.
26.
Gafurov, B. G. Tadzhiki. Drevneishaya, drevnyaya i srednevekovaya istoriya [Tekst] / Bobodzhon Gafurovich Gafurov M.: Nauka, 1972. s.54
27.
Davydov, A.D. Afganskaya derevnya (sel'skaya obshchina i rassloenie krest'yanstva) [Tekst] / A.D. Davydov. M.: Nauka, 1969. S. 70.
28.
Sm.: Hassan, I. H. Islam: A religious, political, social and economic study [Text] / I. H. Hassan. Baghdad: The Times Printing and Publishing, 1967. R. 328.
29.
Narshakhi, M. Ta''rikhi Bukhoro (Istoriya Bukhary) [Tekst] / Abu-Bakr Mukhammad ibn Dzhafar an-Narshakhi. Per. s persidskogo N. Lykoshina. Pod red. V.V. Bartol'da. Tashkent: 1897. S. 2021. A takzhe sm.: Narshakhi, Ta'rikhi Bukhoro [Tekst] / Narshakhi Abubakr Mukhammad binni Cha'far Khozirkunandai chop, muқaddima, tartibdikhandai tavzekhot, luғat, ismkhoi khos, nomkhoi chuғrofi N. Kosimov. Mukharriri mas''ul. A. Mukhtorov / Abubakr Mukhammad binni Cha'far Narshakhi. Dushanbe: Donish, 1979. 118 s.
30.
See: Hassan, I. H. Islam: a religious, political, social and economic study [Text] / I. H. Hassan. Baghdad: The Times Printing and Publishing, 1967. 586 p.
31.
Goldberg, E. Khatima Nadhariyawa-Tarikhiya. Ukaz. rab. P. 286.
32.
Sm.: Istoriya Irana s drevneishikh vremen do kontsa XVIII veka [Tekst] / Red. I.V. Pigulevskaya i dr. L.: Izd-vo LGU, 1958. 384 s.
33.
Abd al-Aziz al-Dury Mugadima fi al-Tarihk al-Iqtasadi al-Arabi [Text] / Abd al-Aziz al-Dury. Idar al-Tali'a. Beirut, 1969. R. 69.
34.
Klyuchevskii, V.O. Russkaya istoriya. Polnyi kurs lektsii v trekh knigakh [Tekst] / Vasilii Osipovich Klyuchevskii Kn. 1. Rostov n/D.: Izd-vo Feniks, 2000. S. 166168.
35.
Sm.: Goldberg, E. Private Goods, Public Wrongs and Civil Society in Some Medieval Arab Theory and Practice [Text] / Goldberg E. // in E.Goldberg, R.Kasaba and J.Migdal, ed. Rules and Rights in Middle East London and Seattle, 1993. P. 253.
36.
Sm.: Shakhmatov, V. F. Kazakhskaya pastbishchno-kochevaya obshchina: voprosy preobrazovaniya, evolyutsii i razlozheniya [Tekst] / V. F. Shakhmatov. Alma-Ata: Izd-vo AN Kazakhskoi SSR, 1964. S. 47.
37.
Sotsial'nyi stroi i politiko-pravovoe ustroistvo kazakhskogo obshchestva v XVII nachale XIX vv. [Elektronnyi resurs] http://wap.history1997.forum24.ru/?1-2-20-00000018-000-0-0-1233331333. Zaglavie s ekrana. Data obrashcheniya: [28.02.2012].
38.
Abramzon, S. M. Kirgizy i ikh etno-geneticheskie i istoriko-kul'turnye svyazi [Tekst] / S.M. Abramzon. Frunze: Kyrgyzstan, 1990. S. 129.
39.
Sm.: Hodgson, M. The Venture of Islam: Conscience and History in a World Civilization [Text] / M. Hodgson. Vol. 1: The classical Age of Islam. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1974. R. 18.
40.
Cm.: Blanchard I. Ukaz. rab.
41.
Sait Institutsional'naya ekonomika Neoliberalizm v stranakh latinskoi Ameriki. Kritika s pozitsii Karla Polan'i Deniel D. E. Raundz Perevod M.A. Usacheva www.r-reforms.ru/pollat.htm
42.
Sm.: Istoriya politicheskikh i pravovykh uchenii uchebnik dlya vuzov pod obshch. red. V.V. Kruglova.-M.: NORMA, 2008 .
43.
Sm.: Mallitskii, N. G. Tashkentskie makhallya i mauza [Tekst] / N.G. Mallitskii. // Sb. V.V. Bartol'd: Turkestanskie druz'ya, ucheniki i pochitateli. Tashkent, 1927. S. 108121.
44.
Material iz Vikipedii svobodnoi entsiklopedii. Makhallya [Elektronnyi resurs] http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/makhallya/ Zaglavie s ekrana. Data obrashcheniya: [05.05.2011].
45.
Sm.: Madzhi, A. E. Iz istorii feodal'nogo Khodzhenta [Tekst] / A.E.Madzhi // v kn.: Materialy po istorii tadzhikov i Tadzhikistana. Sb. 1-i. Stalinabad: Gos. izdat pri SNK Tadzh. SSR, 1945. S.114145.
46.
Sm.: Kolpakov, A.P. Nekotorye svedeniya o kvartalakh dorevolyutsionnogo g. Kulyaba [Tekst] / A.P.Kolpakov // Izv. Otdeleniya obshchestvennykh nauk AN Tadzh. SSR. Vyp. 5. Stalinabad, 1954. S. 79.
47.
Abdullaev K. Said Alim Khan i "bukharskaya revolyutsiya" Istoriya v litsakh. Poslednii mangyt http://my.mail.ru/community/buxoro/journal
48.
Savitskii, A. P. Pozemel'nyi vopros v Turkestane (v proektakh i zakonakh 18671886 gg.) [Tekst] / A.P. Savitskii. Tashkent: Izd-vo SAGU, 1963. S. 44.
49.
Tam zhe. S. 46.
50.
Tsit. po: Abashin, S. N. Byt' ili ne byt' obshchine v Turkestane: spory v russkoi administratsii v 18601880 godakh [Tekst] / S.N. Abashin // Vestnik Evrazii. 2001. 4. C. 34.
51.
Sm.: Shakhidi, M. Osiei Markazi. Khudshinosi, Chakhonshinosi va sulkhsozi dar afkori adabi [Tekst] / Munira Shakhidi. Dushanbe: Er-graf, 2004. 130 s
Link to this article

You can simply select and copy link from below text field.


Other our sites:
Official Website of NOTA BENE / Aurora Group s.r.o.
"History Illustrated" Website